Review of Air China flight Taipei Beijing in Economy

Airline Air China
Flight CA186
Class Economy
Seat 45L
Aircraft Airbus A330-300
Flight time 03:20
Take-off 08 Feb 13, 12:55
Arrival at 08 Feb 13, 16:15
CA   #84 out of 139 Airlines A minimum of 20 Flight-Reports is required in order to appear in the rankings. 180 reviews
marathon
By GOLD 2396
Published on 23rd April 2016
This introduction is tale of a high stakes gamble on plane ticket and visa conditions.

It certainly did not strike you even if you realized that this flight was back in early 2013, but this flight was on the day before Chinese New Year (and the flight back was the day after the Lantern Festival). In other terms, it was the Chinese equivalent of flying on Dec 24th and January 2nd, throwing in Thanksgiving traffic in addition for good measure, and therefore in red in both this calendar and seat availability.

photo P1120179a

Finding an affordable plane ticket in economy out of Taipei with a layover in Mainland China at these dates required a Platinum level determination, because one and a half billion Chinese, Taiwanese and Vietnamese were going to travel at the same time. Even four months ahead of time, it was a formidably challenging task.

I had three options:
- FB award tickets, but the only affordable ones were on CZ flights with a 9 hour layover in CAN, and it was unclear if I could leave the airport to spend time in a rather second rate Chinese city, tourism-wise. There were availabilities in Y+ on the PVG-CDG route, but none on the TPE-PVG leg. A 19’30” phone call to FB’s hotline did not provide me anything better than was available on the website.

- Lion Travel, which had sold me a round trip on SQ on Chinese New Year the previous year, where Ms. Huang recognized me immediately. She was indeed intelligent (this was the meaning of her first name in Chinese), but only in Taiwan could you select Meow as a “Western” first name.

photo business%2520card%2520Huang%2520Ying-zhi

She searched for a long time, and eventually proposed a roundtrip for 50,000 TWD on KL, and 60,000 on CX i.e. about 1,250 EUR and 1,500 EUR at that time. The quality – price ratio was not enough for the former and the price was too much for the latter.

photo P1120162a

- And last, the World Wide, very wide Web, where Matrix had indicated the possibility of an interesting combination of four flights on three different airlines. I searched for two weeks, and I was about to give up when I finally found a German on line travel agency, with a website in German only, which was selling it and had only 4 Plätze verfügbar (4 seats available). A brief exchange of SMS with Mainland China and ten minutes later, I was disposed of a problem and of 878.95 EUR.

TPE – PEK (Air China, A330) YOU ARE HERE
PEK – CDG (Air France, B777)
CDG – PVG (China Eastern, A330)
PVG – TPE (China Eastern, A330)

That was a hard core Economy routing, with an interesting progression starting with a comfortable day flight on Air China, a 9h25’ layover in PEK and then a flight leaving in the middle of the night out of PEK's second rate Terminal 2, sold by MU, but operated by AF (the 3-4-3 steerage class specialist), and a fully MU trip back to TPE, with a 5h30’ layover in PVG to recover from a night in a 332, and a grand finale in a 346 on a short haul flight to TPE.

photo CDG%2520VIA%2520pek%25202

But this was the measure of friendship, because my best Chinese friend lives in PEK, or rather in Beijing, because it would be simple if she was working airside in PEK. She is a Chinese citizen and could not obtain a Taiwanese visa at the time, and conversely it was very difficult for me to obtain a Chinese visa while living in Taiwan.

The administrative loophole that I was counting on was the possibility to enter China without a visa for 24h in Beijing (and 48h in Shanghai) in case of international transit. For Beijing, it was little more than hearsay on the internet (but well documented for Shanghai, and I knew a Flight Reporter who had done it), but it was worth taking a bet on it. Hence the interest of this long evening layover in PEK.

That shaky gamble paid off in early December 2012 : the Beijing authorities announced the setup of the 72 hour visa exemption (which was to be later extended to half a dozen other Chinese cities), on the condition of having a passport of one of 45 countries and flying onward to a different country, which was going to be my case.

Four months elapsed, and the day before my flight, I received this e-mail.

photo airnlinede-maila

Everything seemed OK : they had not forgotten me, and I could even "jetzt online einchecken". The hyperlink pointed at Air China’s German website, which refused to recognize my ticket number, my reservation number and my passport number : nothing worked. I tried Air China’s Taiwanese website, to no avail. And then I had a terrible doubt: was it a bug in Air China’s website (OLCI was a rather new concept in Mainland China), or a problem with my ticket? I shared my anguish with Mrs. Marathon, who noted that I was suggested to book "Ihr Hotel in Paris" and wondered if I really wanted to join her.

What should I do ? Call the hotline in German at 0.14 EUR/min, or bet that everything was OK? I took the bet, but quite frankly, I had a very very bad night. My plan B, checked on the internet, was the availability of an FB award ticket the day after, which would make me lose face, my Friday evening in Beijing with my Chinese friend, my whole Saturday with my wife and 80,000 FB miles plus fuel tax + airport tax. I won’t say which was worst, but all four together were enough to have a very bad night.

[This was the first time I experienced an OLCI failure; I was later to have many other cases and sleep much better when they occurred. There is always a time when you are a rookie.]

Arrival on D-Day at TPE’s Terminal 2, with a taxi because I was moving a maximum of stuff back to France, before my final departure from Taiwan in June that year, with checked luggage at the maximum weight limit and a hand luggage well beyond the weight limit (I knew from experience that they never check the latter in TPE and PEK). The taxi driver that I hailed proposed a flat 1,200 TWD rate. The deal was very slightly better for him because of the very fluid traffic, but a few more red traffic lights would have changed the balance, so it was fair.

photo P1180813a

A yin-yang sculpture in from of the walkway to the parking lots.

photo P1180812a

I had arrived to the airport very early in order to have time to play the phone call card (at 0.14 EUR/min, in German), but I was so anxious that my picture of Air China’s check-in counters was completely blurred.

photo P1180815a

And then…

And then I felt an immense relief when I was confirmed to be indeed booked on that flight and received this BP to PEK, with a window seat at my request.

photo P1180816a

The only problem was that my luggage could only be checked to PEK (same ticket connecting flights were a new concept in Mainland China). They were going to be an embarrassment (because they were at the weight limit of my allowance), and my Chinese friend suggested to meet her at her home rather than in the restaurant. Fortunately, my wife knew her and her unquestionable morality.

That was another major aspect of my visa gamble : without confirmation of the visa exemption, I might not have been able to recover my luggage in PEK, or check in onwards to CDG, for that matter.

photo P1180817a

Contrary to the previous time I had boarded this flight, Flight CA186 was posted on time, and since the plane had already left PEK at the time I took the picture, the prediction was credible.

photo P1180819a

Going through security check was fast ; not only was the staff there smiling, but he spontaneously helped me replace my laptop in its case. I would advise training in Taipei to security staff of some other airports. Note the access to the Evergreen (Eva Air) lounge at the upper level in the background, with its access on the left, just after the immigration counters in the foreground.

photo P1180820a

And since this access overlooks the immigration control zone, I could take this overall picture of the place (I never quite understood what is so sensitive at these nondescript counters, where pictures are prohibited in all countries).

photo P1180824a

I could also take a picture of the Chinese New Year wishes of the Taiwanese immigration.

photo P1180823a

There was a symmetrical China Airlines lounge, providing a similar panoramic view on the other immigration counters.

photo P1180826a

A small sample of the duty free shops, with this tea shop.

photo P1180827a

The inevitable Chinese New year decorations

photo P1180828a

One of many free internet access stations for self-use, without any time limitation or censorship.

photo P1180832a

That provided me the opportunity for a corporate screenshot, with advertising for Taipei-Shaba flights for 2,288 TWD on Air Asia.

photo P1180831a

This is an exhibit on the Pili puppets, which revisit this ancestral art with modern heroic fantasy aesthetics and themes.

photo P1180834a

One of the children play areas

photo P1180835a

With Lego Duplo building blocks, for free use without any supervision

photo P1180839a

With regards to the Alishan narrow gauge railway, a former logging line, which climbs from Chiayi to Alishan, some 2,000 m higher, better wait before placing it on your travel plans : a typhoon destroyed the track in 2012, and as of 2016, traffic only reaches halfway up. (The rehabilitation of the line was initially scheduled to be completed by 2014)

photo P1180841a

There are prayer areas like in JED, but here, there are three next to each other, for Buddhists, Christians…

photo P1180842a

… and Muslims here, with rather nice prayers rugs, the required direction of Makkah and a Quran on a tray table out of this picture.

photo P1180843a

For Chinese New Year, it is a Taiwanese tradition to decorate the entrance of private and professional premises with calligraphies, always in black ink on red paper, and you can often see professional calligraphers propose their services, like here.

photo P1180846a

But there, this was an entirely free workshop, for traveler keen to try this form of art.

photo P1180855a

The plane operating BR’s 13:10 flight to CAN had not arrived yet, which spares you the view of a Hello Kitty A330. But you won’t escape the Hello Kitty nursing room (from the outside)

photo P1180860a

Or a coin operated phone decorated the same.

photo P1180858a

A temporary exhibit on painted umbrellas from Meinong, a village in the south-west of Taiwan, whose population is entirely Hakka, a minority from the province of Fujian (opposite Taiwan on the Mainland). Quite frankly, I was not impressed by Meinong when I visited there.

photo P1180861a

A reading room

photo P1180862a

It was not the best time of the day for plane spotting and the windows were very dirty because of the rain of the preceding days.

photo P1180829a

A CZ A321 had finished its pushback, with an MU A320 in the foreground

photo P1180833a

… there she is

photo P1180840a

A JL 767 JAL, poorly focused

photo P1180844a

CI 738, seen through rather dirty windows

photo P1180864a

Xiamen Airlines 738

photo P1180865a

Arrival of a CX 777

photo P1180869a

A KE aircraft taking off behind a JL 738

photo P1180870a

CZ A320

photo P1180854a

CZ A321

photo P1180838a

VN A321

photo P1180856a

Shenzhen Airlines 738

photo P1180857a

It was time to reach Gate D4, where boarding was imminent.

photo P1180847a

This was the plane which was going to fly me to PEK

photo P1180849a

As promised by the Germans, she was indeed a 333.

photo P1180853a

From the lower level

photo P1180873a

What was interesting about this aircraft was that she was dedicated to flights to Taiwan: the Mainland China flag is missing in the livery, just aft of the first door, unlike this 332 seen when I took this PEK - CSX flight.

photo IMG_9295a

They removed their flag (which must have needed months of behind the scenes negotiations), but the deal apparently said nothing about cleaning the aircraft. Or maybe Air China’s cleaning staff seems to have been trained by that of Air France.

photo P1180875a

Boarding was announced and a long and reasonably orderly line took shape immediately.

photo P1180874a

Two newspapers offered at the entrance of the plane : Mainland China’s China Daily and a newspaper in Chinese that I did not identify

photo P1180876a

The Y cabin, before it was completely full

photo P1180877a

This was going to be my vital space during the 3h5’ of flight announced by the captain. Not bad, wasn’t it?

photo P1180878a

The seat pitch was honorable; the edge of the seat headrest was halfway up my head

photo P1180884a

The safety information card, both sides

photo P1180883a

Some plane spotting during boarding, despite the poor weather conditions

photo P1180885a

A JL 767 JAL taxies away

photo P1180886a

Arrival of a CI A330

photo P1180887a

And of a CI 747

photo P1180889a

Boarding was complete, and we pushed back

photo P1180891a

A CZ A321

photo P1180894a

A Jetstar A320 plying the SIN-TPE-KIX route (with 5th freedom on the TP-KIX leg), which was going to take off just before us

photo P1180895aphoto P1180898a

The safety demonstrations were on the collective IFE screens, in English and Mandarin with sign language translation.

photo P1180897a

Taxiing past a CI A330

photo P1180899a

And in front of a CA A340. You probably guessed that it had started to rain.

photo P1180900a

Taking takeoff pictures required split second action, just after the rain drops on the window had been washed away and just before the low cloud ceiling was reached.

photo P1180901a

The roofs of Terminal 1

photo P1180904a

Looking up, there was of course blue sky

photo P1180909a

And also an undecorated winglet

photo P1180906a

The paint was peeling off on the wing too

photo P1180907a

I always admire the skill of the Taiwanese and the Chinese for taking a nap anytime and anywhere they have a chance.

photo P1180908a

The meal service started with a drink.

photo P1180911a

As usual, I asked for a cup of coffee. It probably came from Taipei, and the taste was to Taiwanese air travel standards, i.e. awful.

photo P1180910a

The FAs had donned an apron for service, as always on Chinese flights. The decoration of Air China’s apron is very similar to that of the standard uniform, and you hardly notice it.

photo P1180918a

The menu was announced orally in Mandarin and English, with the inevitable choice between chicken-rice and beef-noodles. My frequent readers will not be surprised that I chose 鸡肉米饭 jīròu mǐfàn, a.k.a. chicken-rice. The FAs were friendly and efficient, but did not smile. I suspected that the ones assigned to my seating area spoke minimal English, but I did not try using this language.

photo P1180912a

The weak pepper sauce was quite strange, but OK, and the rice was correct. The yogurt was smooth and really excellent. There was no doubt that it was Taiwanese catering too. First of all, because the labeling mentioned that it had been made in Hsinchu, but also because a straw is always provided with a Chinese yogurt for sipping, because there no way you can open a Chinese yogurt the Western (or Taiwanese) way.

photo P1180915a

My neighbor went to the toilets and I did the same for an urgent photographic need. I lowered the lid, because it was dirty, unacceptably dirty, and worn too. Water had been splashed on the sink, too.

photo P1180922a

A rather blurry view of the cabin on the way back

photo P1180921a

The clouds had cleared, but the plain south of Beijing is rather nondescript, especially with a snow cover.

photo P1180923a

The IFE screens shifted to the air show towards the end of the flight

photo P1180926a

It revealed a detour typical of a flight in the Chinese airspace where the air force takes the lion’s share.

photo P1180934a

Did you notice something strange on this map ?

photo P1180931a

An unexpected typo : the capital of Hebei province is Shijiazhuang, with a final g. The sound is very different in Mandarin.

The IFE shifted to the display of connecting flights… including some on the next day. It was also announced that the luggage would be on line 37.

photo P1180936a

Airbrakes

photo P1180941a

The frozen plain

photo P1180946a

Approaching Beijing, and its housing complexes (I jacked up the contrast in the next pictures)

photo P1180949a

The tool gates of the expressway branch to Terminals 1 and 2

photo P1180950a

And the toll gates for Terminal 3

photo P1180952aphoto P1180956a

Terminal 3 is so huge that it seems very flat

photo P1180959a

Some aircraft parked at the international end of Terminal 3 : Qatar and United

photo P1180962a

Two other United

photo P1180963a

Arrival of an Asiana A320

photo P1180967a

Egyptair 332 (SU-GCJ, if you are curious)

photo P1180971a

Lufthansa A340

photo P1180973a

Deplaning : two pictures of the rather small J cabin in this plan in regional configuration.

photo P1180974aphoto P1180975a

And a short walk in Terminal 3

photo P1180977a

It was not obvious at first sight, especially because the eye was attracted by the unusually long lines at the normal immigration counters, but there was a new specific counter for handling the 72 hour exemption. Note far left the keyboard used by travelers to rate the quality of service of the immigration officer.

photo P1180978a

There was no waiting ; the policeman was quite gruff, placed several phone calls to check if the MU flight on my e-ticket print-out was indeed flying to Paris, whatever else, and eventually gave me my passport back with a stamp which took a full page for very little information. I was done much faster than the travelers with an ordinary visa.

photo P1180979a

Now I had to go down and take a people mover

photo P1180980a

And reach the luggage delivery room, where a staff was straightening the incoming suitcases.

photo P1180982a

Mine arrived quite quickly. I went past the crowd of people waiting for passengers. The lifts to Level -1 are undersized (this is a design flaw of that terminal): several passengers gave up taking even slower travellators, and I could board the first one, which was not expected.

photo P1180983a

It was PEK’s world upside down : a long wait at immigration (but not for me), but negligible waiting for a taxi. At 17:01, i.e. ETA+46’, I was in this taxi.

photo P1180984a

The expressway’s toll, already seen during the descent

photo P1180985a

Like this one

photo P1180987a

It was not a usual Friday : the traffic on the expressway was smooth all the way to the Second ring road, and also in the Dongzhimen neighborhood, because many people had already left on vacation, giving me five hours of conversation with my friend before heading back to the airport.

photo P1180988a

This is the end of this FR, and I know offer you a tourist bonus on a seldom visited monument in Beijing.

These were the headquarters of the Chinese army and navy from 1906, in the final years of the weakening Qing dynasty. It entered local history for being the location of the “18 March 1926” massacre, when the police opened fire on Communist and Nationalist demonstrators against the Unequal Treaties, leaving 47 dead and over 200 wounded.

photo P1370086a

This is where Liu HeZhen, a student of the Women's Normal College died : this information would ring a bell to most readers, because 纪念刘和珍君 (In Memory of Miss Liu Hezhen ), an emotional essay by Lu Xun (a major early 20th century writer) has long been required reading in Chinese universities.

photo P1370107a

This plaque, and another one giving the name of the place are the only identification of this place which is absent from tourist guide and hidden behind anondescript entrance alongside ZhangZiZhong Avenue. The buildings are under state protection since 1992, according to this plaque, which does not imply rehabilitation.

photo P1370109a

Brick housings similar to the ones lining The Workers’ Stadium North Avenue (see the bonus of this flight report) have been built after WWII in the vast grounds surrounding the original buildings. One day will probably come when they are replaced by much more upmarket ones, given the location in the heart of Beijing.

photo P1370104a

The original 1906 buildings with their oversized ceilings heights will remain. They had been transformed into housings according to pure Mao era standards, with these semi-collective kitchens in the corridor with locked cupboards for the stores of each family.

photo P1370098a

The buildings were still in decent condition, despite the degradation. It was sometimes difficult to identify what was closed for unspecified repairs, disused or occupied by the elderly residents wandering like waifs. I had a pervasive melancholic feeling in this Sleeping beauty castle, in these utterly silent premises, shielded from the Beijing road traffic din by the thickness of the walls.

photo P1370088aphoto P1370091a

The hodgepodge of used stuff stored everywhere, the linen drying on clothing lines like in all other popular Chinese neighborhoods gave the impression of oversized building of a forgotten civilization invaded by squatters.

photo P1370096a

I have seen similar scenes in second tier cities elsewhere in China, but this place is unusual in Beijing where so many historic buildings have been destroyed to give way to a Disneyland copy or a glass postmodern skyscraper.

photo P1370090a

I took these pictures in 2010, but there is a fair chance that nothing changed since. If you check it out and find out it did change, let me know !
See more

Verdict

Air China

7.6/10
Cabin8.5
Cabin crew7.5
Entertainment/wifi7.0
Meal/catering7.5

Taipei - TPE

9.5/10
Efficiency10.0
Access9.0
Services9.0
Cleanliness10.0

Beijing - PEK

9.0/10
Efficiency9.0
Access9.0
Services8.0
Cleanliness10.0

Conclusion

The flight was rigorously on time. The food was to Chinese standards (and the coffee was unfortunately to Taiwanese standards). The comfort was very good for Economy. My only regret was the absence of smile from the FAs.

Both airports were easy to reach by taxi ; public transportation would have been inconvenient with the amount of luggage that I had.

Information on the route Taipei (TPE) Beijing (PEK)

The contributors of Flight-Report published 10 reviews of 4 airlines on the route Taipei (TPE) → Beijing (PEK).


Useful

The airline with the best average rating is China Airlines with 8.3/10.

The average flight time is 3 hours and 14 minutes.

  More information

4 Comments

  • Comment 162789 by
    jish.b SILVER 258 Comments

    Nice FR buddy, and some pretty nice pictures to go with it!

    Ahh Taipei Taoyuan! I have had great memories of that airport! Lovely spotting pictures.

    I;m surprised that the A330 did not have any in flight entertainment - are these used primarily for domestic/regional routes?

    Jish

    • Comment 346477 by
      marathon GOLD AUTHOR 9580 Comments

      Not only this plane was used for domestic / regional routes, but this one was dedicated to Taiwan flights. I forgot to mention this interesting detail and updated my report to point out at the telltale hint.

      Thanks for reminding me about it, and for your comment !

  • Comment 162961 by
    jetsetpanda 2295 Comments

    Thank you Marathon for sharing another interesting FR with a fascinating and little known bonus.

    You went through a roller coaster of emotions when you purchased this ticket. I don't think that I could have managed the uncertainties as well as you did. In the end I am glad that it worked out for you and everything turned out fine. Most importantly, you did not lose face. ;)

    It's reassuring to read about the nice security personnel at TPE airport. One airport that I experienced that kind of professionalism was HND when I flew out of there a few years ago. It's eye opening to see how civil security screening can be when one travels outside of the U.S., especially in Asia.

    TPE airport looks spacious and quirky with the Hello Kitty and children's corners - they are unique features that set that airport apart and give them character. It's also nice that internet and computer terminals are provided.

    Great observation about the slightly modified airplane serving the Taiwanese market. As a matter of fact, it reminds of a similar modification by KL with the KL Asia name.

    Nice plane spotting and aerials. It's a shame that you CA plane was so dirty. Service onboard looks solid but a few smiles would have been better as you said. Perhaps things have changed for the better after your trip. I find it somewhat odd that yogurt is served on a Chinese carrier and during lunch, considering that a large number of Chinese are lactose intolerant.

    See you on your next report.

    • Comment 346592 by
      marathon GOLD AUTHOR 9580 Comments

      “You went through a roller coaster of emotions when you purchased this ticket. (…) Most importantly, you did not lose face. ;)”
      - You know what counts most in Chinese culture :)

      “It's reassuring to read about the nice security personnel at TPE airport. (…) It's eye opening to see how civil security screening can be when one travels outside of the U.S., especially in Asia.”
      - CDG used to have awful security staff, but they made spectacular improvements in the past few years. I just had a very pleasant experience there. Good management can turn things around quickly, if there is a will.

      “TPE airport looks spacious and quirky with the Hello Kitty and children's corners - they are unique features that set that airport apart and give them character. It's also nice that internet and computer terminals are provided.”
      - I have no personal interest in that character, but I love this Hello Kitty theme in TPE, because it is part of what makes this airport so unlike others.

      “Great observation about the slightly modified airplane serving the Taiwanese market. As a matter of fact, it reminds of a similar modification by KL with the KL Asia name.”
      - Similar reason, indeed. Once upon the time, JAL also had a subsidiary called Japan Asia Airways dedicated to Taiwan flights.

      “Nice plane spotting and aerials. It's a shame that you CA plane was so dirty. Service onboard looks solid but a few smiles would have been better as you said. Perhaps things have changed for the better after your trip.”
      - CA never was my favorite Chinese airline; although I have a hard time identifying why.

      I find it somewhat odd that yogurt is served on a Chinese carrier and during lunch, considering that a large number of Chinese are lactose intolerant.”
      - Yogurt is very common in Chinese stores. I guess those who are intolerant are used to stay away from it.

      See you on your next report.
      - A brand new series of 2016 Asian flights is coming up soon. Stay tuned, and meanwhile, thanks for your comments !

Login to post a comment.