Review of Lufthansa flight Munich Shanghai in First

Airline Lufthansa
Flight LH726
Class First
Seat ALL
Aircraft Airbus A340-600
Flight time 11:05
Take-off 09 Mar 18, 22:00
Arrival at 10 Mar 18, 16:05
LH   #49 out of 123 Airlines A minimum of 20 Flight-Reports is required in order to appear in the rankings. 898 reviews
socalnow
By GOLD 2731
Published on 28th March 2018
Greetings Flight Report community and thanks for stopping by. I plan to share a series of flights that provided a chance to try several First Class products and lounges that were new to me and also enjoy some familiar but fantastic experiences along the way. A while back I had enough Krisflyer miles in my account to wait list for SQ25. This is a tough nut to crack for us mere mortals. (Rewardflying uses Jedi mind tricks to secure space on a whim.) I went about searching the SQ award engine for the rest of the year and wait listed on the only 4 dates (that could possibly work with my schedule) where even wait listing was available. I wait listed for both JFK-FRA and JFK-SIN. Fast forward several months and the magic email arrives telling me I have 48 hours to confirm my booking but only on the JFK-FRA segment. I'll take it!

If I'm going to be in FRA and flying Star Alliance I will all too sad not to drop in on my German friends and their spectacular lounges. The problem is I cannot book LH F through Krisflyer until space opens two weeks prior to departure. This date would come after my 48 hour window to book SQ. In comes the trusty Star Alliance member Asiana and their ever present F availability. I booked JFK-FRA-ICN on SQ and OZ as a place holder until LH comes calling. The SQ change fees are so very minimal it was worth it to me to have something. Worst case scenario is 10 hours in an OZ A380 suite. Concurrently I place flight alerts on Expert Flyer for just about every LH flight heading east form either FRA or MUC. The two week window arrives and the emails start flying in. Well, not really. FRA-PEK, FRA-PVG and, most interesting to me, MUC-PVG all offer O class space. Munich piques my interest as I have never done LH F from there and I know they have a new F lounge as well as a remodeled F lounge. Oh and expert Flyer was showing F8 for MUC-PVG.

I can't leave the table while I'm up so I start looking for where to go after PVG on this ticket. I would like to get to Tokyo but the connections don't work without an 8 hour wait. International to International MCT at PVG is 2 ours, just FYI so the other options didn't allow enough time. What about Osaka? I do like Osaka a great deal for night time food and adult beverage consumption. Plus, it's closer to Tokyo… Great, let's add PVG-KIX and book this thing! The Krisflyer rep on the phone had me hold to verify this was a legal routing but I'm confident. Shortly I have an email confirming JFK-FRA-MUC-PVG-KIX. What fun!

Now to get to JFK. I had a little snafu, you may have read about, with a ticket issued by American Airlines. Due to a date error i wasn't able to use it when I expected. I think I will try to use these miles/ticket to get to JFK. Then, in a somewhat miracle fashion, the points blogosphere blows up with news of AA releasing a lot of F and J space on the LAX-JFK transcon routes. Normally this is none. OK, this was meant to be. I look up my date and low and behold it's there. F space from LAX-JFK that fits perfectly. A call to AA and a super agent even waived all the fees. She siad technically I'm upgrading to a higher class of service so she can waive the change fee on the award ticket. Never mind that the city pairs had changed… I had to kick in 20k extra miles but i was excited to try the new AA F experience with new lounges and dining.

There is now one hole. TYO-LAX. I suppose you know how that ends. ANA of course. My favorite redemption, for 110k Virgin Atlantic Flying Club miles, I booked NRT-LAX-NRT with the outbound to complete this mission and the return to begin another adventure in November. Enough talk, let's fly.

Behold the visual representation courtesy of gcmap.com:

photo map

Carrier, route, equipment, class, lounge, and procurement method:




American Airlines - LAX-JFK - A321T - First - Flagship Lounges and Flagship First Dining - Advantage Miles

Singapore Airlines - JFK-FRA - A380-800 - Suites - Virgin Atlantic Clubhouse - Krisflyer
Lufthansa - FRA-MUC - A320 - Business - First Class Terminal (Bonus Porsche Experience)- Krisflyer
Lufthansa - MUC-PVG - A340-600 - First - First Class Lounge(s) - Krisflyer (This Report)
ANA - PVG-KIX - 767-300ER - Business - Air China Lounge - Krisflyer
Japan Airlines - ITM-NRT - 767-300ER - Business - No Lounge (Bonus Narita Walk) - Cash
ANA - NRT-LAX - 777-300ER - First - Suites Lounge(s) - Virgin Atlantic Flying Club (Coming Soon)

Lufthansa First Class Lounges - Munchen



I dropped off the rental car and retraced my steps back to Terminal 2. I noticed the advertisement for the LH A380 coming to MUC.



I followed the signs to Lufthansa First Class check in and used the security screening there. I don't know if it was any faster as none of the lines looked very busy.

photo 20180309_091148

First stop was the old (now remodeled) First Class Lounge in the main building. This lounge is just adjacent to my departure gate but, wory not, I'll make the trip out to the Satellite lounge as well.

The entry on the 1st floor. The lounge is one level up. You turn over your passport to the immigration office stationed just outside the lounge entrance.

photo 20180309_092432

Even on my first visit the lounge had a familiar feel and aesthetic.

photo 20180309_093028photo 20180309_093027

To the left of the entry is the bar and just beyond is the buffet and dining area.

photo 20180309_093016photo 20180309_102350

As soon as I enter I am approached by lounge staff, females dressed in traditional Bavarian Dirndl, and offered service. Something to drink, a look around, etc. It's quite the opposite of the Frankfurt experience. I am slightly overwhelmed and decline as of now. I will get my bearings and then circle back.

The space is compact and nicely sectioned off to avoid a large hall feeling.



The Cigar Lounge is present.

photo 20180309_093216

The tables throughout the lounge are adorned with snacks, similar to FRA. There are different snacks in MUC.


Fruit tower.
photo 20180309_102416 2

Having snooped about I was ready to enjoy the dining room and buffet. I chose a seat and was presented a moist towel and offered a beverage.

photo 20180309_093416photo 20180309_094030

I requested the Champagne Pommery Cuvee Louise 2004.

photo 20180309_094626 2

Each table was adorned with pretzels hung from antlers.

photo 20180309_093915 2

There were two menus available.

The standard menu
photo 20180309_093454 2
1
photo 20180309_093534 2
2
photo 20180309_093534 3
3
photo 20180309_093551 2
4
photo 20180309_093620 2
5
photo 20180309_093620 3

Promotional menu. The Starkbierzeit is the strong beer festival.
photo 20180309_093708 2
1
photo 20180309_093715 2
2
photo 20180309_093715 3
3
photo 20180309_093726 2
4
photo 20180309_093726 3

The specials were listed on an additional flyer.

photo 20180309_093612 2

If that isn't enough choice there is a beautiful buffet.



I can't find where it was listed but I started with a truffled beef carpaccio with horseradish cream. It was beautifully presented and had lovely flavors.

photo 20180309_095133photo 20180309_095137

I was tempted by many of the offerings but could not get past the schweinefleisch: crispy suckling pig / bread dumpling / Jersey cabbage / Stout jus. This one didn't fare as well. Although beautiful to look at the skin was chewy and the meat was not as tender as expected. Perhaps this is good, it saved me from eating too much of it. The bread dumplings and sauce were spot on.

photo 20180309_101011photo 20180309_101015

Service throughout the meal was exceptional. I think I counted 3 servers tending to the 5 (at most) occupied tables. The woman taking care of me was a spectacular Bavarian blond bombshell, so that was nice as well.

Bath time is up next. There is no wait to use the facilities. The bath check in desk has drinks and snacks too, just in case you missed all of the other food on your way back to the showers.

photo 20180309_093153

I was assigned a bath room with Jacuzzi tub.



There is also a toilet, sink, and shower. Alas, no Etro toiletries.



Shower with multiple shower heads.
photo 20180309_104043 2

Some familiar slippers were also included.
photo 20180309_104201

I can't forget this quintessential addition to the collection.

photo 20180309_102937

Feeling refreshed and positively delighted by my stay I consulted with the staff about venturing over to the Satellite lounge to have a look. After all is was the latest greatest. Even though my flight was leaving from a gate quite near this lounge. Normally these types of shenanigans are received by the staff as confusing but in this case they were wholly supportive and excited that I wanted to see their facilities. We covered the basics in how to get there and how much time to leave to get back. Unbeknownst to me they called the other lounge when I was walking just to give them a heads up and probably ask for help getting me back here in time to depart.

The K and L gates are accessed by a train.
photo 20180309_112142photo 20180309_112211

The new terminal is beautiful. I will have to make time on a future visit to explore.

photo 20180309_112818

The FCL here has a rather austere entrance from this level. It's interesting as they have access from this level for Schengen passengers and the top level for non-Schengen. I think. I was rather tired and confused by how it works but I think that they stamped my out of Germany at this lounge so I returned to the flight as a non-Schengen. Anyhow, as with the other FCL, I turned over my passport to the immigration officer stationed outside the lounge entrance.

photo 20180309_113014

I was welcomed by name and told they had been alerted to my visit from the other lounge staff. I also get a nice guided tour with one of the front desk staff. A strong service move.

This lounge has a long L shape. Basically two long hallways. It also seems far larger. Perhaps double the size.

First "hall".
photo 20180309_113353
Second "hall".
photo 20180309_113357

Work spaces.
photo 20180309_113419

Row of seating facing the ramp, my favorite seats in this space.

photo 20180309_113735

Again the design is a collection of more intimate seating areas. As in other LH FCLs there is a snack of some sort on almost every surface int he seating areas.




The dining room here is not only larger but offers ramp views as well.



The food selection was nearly identical to the main terminal FCL.



I'll enjoy a refreshment during my visit and a nibble on the more interesting looking charcuterie.



As boarding time approaches I thank the staff and we discuss my return to the gate. They recommend taking care of the immigration formalaties at their lounge and returning to the gate on a different level (non-Schengen I presume). I visit the immigration desk and am on my way. This time I reenter the terminal on the same level as the lounge.

LH726 MUC-PVG



I ride the train back and I am segregated from all of the other passengers. I suppose it's unusual to travel in this direction at this time.

photo 20180309_121919photo 20180309_122102

I get to the gate at the advertised boarding time but boarding has not begun. In fact it's almost 30 minutes until we do. In that span there is one announcement saying there is a delay with no estimate of boarding time. We we finally do board it's a scrum with a call for First, Hon, and Business coming after those who require extra time and families. I am among the first to board as I happen to be standing near the lane that opens first. Poor showing here Lufty.

photo 20180309_122807


All is forgiven as I board the Lufthansa A340-600 for the very first time. I am warmly and promptly welcomed and informed that the cabin is all mine tonight. This could be a very memorable flight indeed, depending on the crew. Spoiler alert, they were fantastic.

I take some pictures of the cabin, mindful not to disturb the other passengers. :P



The bar is setup for pre-departure beverage service.

photo 20180309_124420photo 20180309_124422

I am promptly refreshed and showered with gifts. Pommery Cuvee Louise 2003 is on offer. Funny with the 2004 in the FCLs.



A bit of an odd amenities kit.
photo 20180309_125529photo 20180309_125525 2

A trip to the lav to change into the lounge wear. Surprisingly there is no wait. As usual it's well stocked.


A
photo 20180309_165649 2

Soon we push back and make our way to 08L for departure.

There are two flight attendants serving the F cabin tonight, on in the aisle and one in the galley. The FA providing the service could not be more delightful. Turns out she is a part time FA. Maybe that's why she still enjoys her work? ;) Anyhow we have wonderful chats on the food, wine, her travels, my travels, and family. She is the perfect blend of formal by the book service and informal personality. I opt to start the meal straight away and request to continue with the Pommery Cuvee Louise 2003.

photo 20180309_134338 2

The Champagne is served with an amuse and warm towel. The rose pedal is one example of attention to detail that I would be the benefactor of for the entire flight.



The wine list for tonight.



The menu.

photo 20180309_140054 2
1
photo 20180309_140110 2
2
photo 20180309_140110 3
3
photo 20180309_140116 2
4
photo 20180309_140116 3

The stage is set and the show is about to begin.

photo 20180309_140145

Caviar to start as my usual preference. I was somewhat surprised that they setup the entire cart with all the trimmings. I don't think I would have been to critical if they had plated in the galley. I much prefer the show so i was tickled to see it put on for an audience of one. As you would expect the portion was beyond generous. I wonder why they can't have a proper caviar spoon? I was hoping to try the Alain Ducasse Grey Goose Vodka but it was not provisioned on this flight. The standard Grey Goose was substituted. There was a note in the bar cart saying the Ducasse vodka was unavailable for March.



I was offered a second portion of caviar and of course accepted. In another mark of excellence the FA cleared all of the plates and brought fresh garnishes (egg, creme fresh, etc.) and then presented the second portion. Could ANA and LH have merged to create a super airline?

The caviar was cleared and the cart was brought back with the appetizers. Of course I was going to taste them all anyway but the FA's enthusiasm to do so made it even more enjoyable. For my tastes the goat cheese tart was the best of the lot.



The salad was served next. I opted for the "Spanish Dressing." I didn't use the butter but I get a kick out of the stamp.



For the main I selected the monkfish with shiitake stock, macadamia not and green pea hummus. Unfortunately it was not an enjoyable dish. The fish was overdone with a rubber like texture. Also, I was just a down right ugly plate. I taste all of the components but that's all. Of course offers are extended for a different main but that will not be necessary, there is already too much.

photo 20180309_144947photo 20180309_144951

I selected the Albarino from Spain to enjoy with the fish. It fared far better than the food.

photo 20180309_144437 2

LH service procedures dictate the cheese cart is offered so that was presented next. The fruit beautifully arranged as well. Being the only passenger I didn't have to be self conscious about ogling the cheese and capturing pictures. I asked to enjoy the cheese now and take a dessert in a bit.

photo 20180309_150932photo 20180309_150946

I had my eye on one of the red wines to enjoy with the cheese. The 2012 Stellenbosch Cab/Merlot. Perhaps my conversation about travel earlier wiht the FA influenced my decision. She was very high on Cape Town and the wine making regions adjacent. Anyhow it was a excellent choice for me.

photo 20180309_151245 2

And of course the cheeses.

photo 20180309_151334photo 20180309_151339

I was encouraged to sample the Nieport 20 years old tawny as well. If I must.

photo 20180309_152353 2

Beautiful color.
photo 20180309_152434 2

After lingering with the red wine and cheese I surrendered the plates and opted for the chocolate cremeux and mango sorbet dessert. It was quite lovely and light.

photo 20180309_152525photo 20180309_152533

After dessert I was asked if I wold like some coffee or tea. I declined but indicated that I was interested in a digestif and I will give it some thought and get back to her. Of course a professional identifies this as an opportunity to exceed expectations and delight your guest. The FA arranged the offerings she thought I might consider on the cart and brought it out to display. Above and beyond, I'd say.

photo 20180309_153637

My choice. Always excited to try a new (to me) dram.

photo 20180309_153649 2

Of course the chocolate is about and finds it's way to me. The pour on the Scotch, oh my.

photo 20180309_153746photo 20180309_153900

Reflecting on the amazing hospitality I have experienced this evening as we glide seemingly effortlessly over Russia.

photo 20180309_155202photo 20180309_161053

During boarding, when I was informed that I was the only guest today in F, we joked about how to use all the space. Perhaps start the meal in 1A, take the main in 2A, etc. She mentioned she would put the bed wherever I desired. I joked about 2k so I could star gaze from bed. I thought we would revisit this subject when bed time rolled around but the FA was so awesome she took initiative and setup a lovely bed in 2K. It's a wonderful spot but it does require passing through the galley to get from seat to bed. It certainly doesn't bother me but I feel as if I am intruding on their space when I do so. The lavs are in the cabin so there really is no reason to breach the curtain and go in the kitchen area. Except to get from the A aisle to the K aisle. I wasn't about to ask her to move it so I will do my best to not to switch between the two. I know, it's a heavy load to bear.

Before turning in for the night I decided to take a stroll about the aircraft. The main goal of the excursion was to see for myself the lavatories located on the cargo level of the airplane. What a brilliant idea. The are in fact downstairs.

photo 20180309_165129
A
photo 20180309_165139 2
B
photo 20180309_165316

Walking through the J and Y cabins i couldn't help but think, "None of you wanted to burn some miles and upgrade to F?!?!" This seems like the perfect flight to do so. The J and Y cabins were hot and crowded. It was quite the stark comparison returning to the cool dark F cabin.

I finally overcame my excitement of being on this beautiful aircraft with a private cabin and tried to lay down to rest.

photo 20180309_170523 2photo 20180309_170529

It was a tad eerie to be alone in the darkened cabin. The heavy curtains (lead I think) that LH has between cabins really seal off the area. I was able to have a solid sleep and awake in tomet o enjoy the breakfast show.

photo 20180309_170558

Awake and returned to 2A I open the shade to inspect the landscape below. I was confident the flood of light wouldn't bother the other passengers.

photo 20180309_204339

We are heading south on one of those wacky Chinese airspace routes.

photo 20180309_214706

Passing through the galley on way over I was offered some coffee or juice and I requested a cappuccino and some water.

photo 20180309_204809

At about 90 minutes out I am asked if I would like to begin breakfast. Yes, please. At this time request the pineapple and coconut smoothie.

photo 20180309_220036 2

Then the full cart breakfast service begins. My goodness the time and care to present this in such a fashion for just me.

photo 20180309_215600photo 20180309_215602

I ask for a taste of each of the meats, cheeses, and berries to start. The flight attendant mentions that some of the caviar remains from the dinner service and perhaps I would enjoy another serving now? Um, yes, that is a next level idea. Perhaps with your scrambled eggs? Uh huh, please.

photo 20180309_215835
A
photo 20180309_215842
B
photo 20180309_220442 2


Of course in my head I am picturing a dollop of caviar on some nice fluffy eggs. Her vision was a bit more decadent. It would appear that I have polished off the entire tin of caviar at this point. In hindsight I should have had some Champagne.

photo 20180309_220907photo 20180309_220920

I ready myself for arrival. Change of clothes, brushing of teeth, half arsed arrangement of hair. Some coffee as we descend.

photo 20180309_230057

Close to the field now.

photo 20180309_232612photo 20180309_233319

Chasing the shadow down.

photo 20180309_233452photo 20180309_233456

The taxi was long, all the way to the opposite side of the airport. As we pulled in I spotted another A340-600. These beauties are all to rare these days.

photo 20180309_235045photo 20180309_235214

Some final goodbyes and an escort past the J passengers to the L2 door and I was off to enter China, with the sole purpose of my visit to leave China. Of course I was greeted with the LH F sign, along with one other HON Circle (I presume. Why aren't YOU riding in front?!?) passenger and escorted to Immigration, placed in a short VIP line, and then met after only to inform the kind woman that I have no baggage and can find my way from there.
See more

Verdict

Lufthansa

8.8/10
Cabin9.0
Cabin crew9.0
Entertainment8.5
Meal/catering8.5

Lufthansa First Class Lounge

9.0/10
Comfort9.0
Meal/catering9.0
Entertainment9.0
Services9.0

Munich - MUC

9.0/10
Efficiency9.0
Access9.0
Services9.0
Cleanliness9.0

Shanghai - PVG

7.4/10
Efficiency6.0
Access9.0
Services7.0
Cleanliness7.5

Conclusion

The Ground Service: MUC didn't whisk me away in an S-Class so it cannot compare to FRA. In fact the boarding in general was unrefined.

The Lounge: They're beautiful and more service minded then the FRA versions. The food and beverage were top notch and I appreciated the local Bavarian touches. The satellite lounge has an open air viewing/lounge area that was of course shuttered for night and winter. The lounge agent opened it for me after I expressed interest but it was too dark for photos. I imagine this would be most lovely in spring and summer.

The Cabin: Already a visually pleasing place to spend time having all 8 seats to yourself is rather unreal.

The Crew: Exquisite service above and beyond my expectations. This is instantly one of my all time most memorable flights.

The Food and Beverage: The main was a total miss but the balance delivered and enjoyable culinary tour. The whole tin of caviar is food porn to the highest degree.

Overall: What a special experience to have the entire cabin as my playground and a fun and engaging crew to pair with it. If the FA had been a frumpy Frau I can imagine how being alone in F could become a bit tedious. This was anything but.

Thank you for reading and happy flying.

Related

17 Comments

  • Comment 438940 by
    sotto 29 Comments

    I cannot understand the appraisal system of the author: LH served on the flight LH726 MUC PVG in FC a Bavarian Starkbier- special menu- The author writes of "miss". As nreakfast was served scrambled eggs with a lot of caviar and the author writes of "miss". Overall his rating within meal/cstering is 8,5 only.
    By contrast, Bifi or Mars bars are also rated at 8.5 on other airlines.

    How are the relations given? Or are there such a policy at all?
    Here, more transparency would be appropriate.

    • Comment 438978 by
      socalnow GOLD AUTHOR 737 Comments

      Greetings Sotto, thanks for the note, I think.

      That's the thing about rankings, they're rather subjective by nature.

      For some reason I feel compelled to respond to your message. It's a slow day at work.

      "LH served on the flight LH726 MUC PVG in FC a Bavarian Starkbier- special menu- The author writes of "miss"."
      -Incorrect. The Bavarian Starkbier- special menu was in the lounge. Even though the dish I ordered form this special menu wasn't great overall I rated the dining in the lounge a 9 (on a scale of 1-10 that is quite high).

      "As nreakfast was served scrambled eggs with a lot of caviar and the author writes of "miss". Overall his rating within meal/cstering is 8,5 only."
      -Incorrect again (You are consistent if nothing else). The "miss" was on the rather poor showing of the main dish. Yes, in my experience, a pile of caviar, some nice cheese, and an assortment of other dishes ranging from passable to poor gets an 8.5. If you want to see what a 9 looks like please see any of my reports on ANA or JAL First Class.

      “By contrast, Bifi or Mars bars are also rated at 8.5 on other airlines.”
      -See above about ratings being subjective. I’ll add that life experience is a large factor in whether a “Bifi” is an 8.5.

      “How are the relations given? Or are there such a policy at all?
      Here, more transparency would be appropriate.”
      -I hope I have been able to illuminate your understanding of my methodology with the above.

      I’m sure you simply forgot to add the thank you for taking the time and effort to prepare such a report for public consumption. You’re welcome.

      Happy flying Sotto.

    • Comment 438997 by
      Andyw 20 Comments

      Yes, this seems to be an odd review, the numbers do not match the report words.

  • Comment 438995 by
    Andyw 20 Comments

    Firstly thankyou for taking the time and effort to once again do a fine trip report.

    I do have to tend with Sotto though, where some people get too excited on their first trip in first or business you seem to go the other way, perhaps because of that?

    You seemed really enthused about it, and nothing went wrong, in fact it more than met expectations, and then you give marks like that?

    Tell me what gets a 10 across the board for any trip you do so I can then have some measuring stick for your next review.

    Cheers

    I find it hard to read what you got on your flight,

    • Comment 438999 by
      socalnow GOLD AUTHOR 737 Comments

      Thanks for the note Andyw.

      "I do have to tend with Sotto though, where some people get too excited on their first trip in first or business you seem to go the other way, perhaps because of that?"
      -I don't understand this analogy.

      "You seemed really enthused about it, and nothing went wrong, in fact it more than met expectations, and then you give marks like that?"
      -Is 8.8/10 a poor mark?

      "Tell me what gets a 10 across the board for any trip you do so I can then have some measuring stick for your next review."
      -I don't believe I've experienced a 10. I would have to guess it looks like Emirates new F hard product with JAL/ANA catering and Singapore Airlines service?

      "I find it hard to read what you got on your flight,"
      -I'm sorry, I don't understand.

      Thanks again and happy flying.

  • Comment 438998 by
    Andyw 20 Comments

    Also leave off the snarky comments you did to Sotto, if you publish you have to take the rough with the smooth when people disagree. Fact of internet life.

    • Comment 439000 by
      socalnow GOLD AUTHOR 737 Comments

      Hi again Andyw and thanks for deleting your post with the foul language. It's better without. I'm happy to take all feedback and tried to explain my thinking/rating. That's about all we can do here in Internet life.

      Happy flying.

  • Comment 439004 by
    KévinDC TEAM GOLD 4475 Comments

    Hi Socalnow, thanks for another amazing report! While healthy debate is always good, and everyone is entitled to his or her own opinion, I am genuinely surprised to see the criticism about the grading. Personally, I find your grades to be more then fair, and you more than adequately make your case in the report itself. Like you say, grades are subjective, it's all based on your personal experience and a comparison with past experiences. As evidenced by your many reports, it is clear that you have a lot of experience flying in Intl First on many of the world's top carriers. So while grades are generally subjective, I fully trust your judgement as it comes from a place of knowledge, experience, and understanding of the different products. Your opinions are always fair and balanced.

    I'm always leery of people who so easily put 10/10 across the board. To me a 10/10 is the ABSOLUTE BEST possible product in the world. No one carrier, 5-star or not, can really claim to be the best at everything. IMO a perfect score would need to start with an AF CDG type F class lounge (or LH FRA FCT), with a mix of JL/NH and AF F type catering, and a new SQ or EK type cabin (or even EY F apartments).

    You make it clear that this was a very special experience--a F cabin all to yourself with the crew going the extra mile is just amazing. But like you said, the catering wasn't perfect. Caviar is great and should always be on offer in intl F, but looking at the menu, while the options look generally appetizing, I don't see anything that stands out as worthy of a 10/10, which would entail more high-end products, especially proteins such as foie gras, lobster, duck, etc. To me chicken, beef, or fish just isn't that exciting for First class.

    LH F is one of the the most well-rounded F products out there and your report reflects that perfectly. Thanks again for taking us on your adventures!

    • Comment 439055 by
      socalnow GOLD AUTHOR 737 Comments

      Greetings KévinDC and thank you for the comments.

      "I am genuinely surprised to see the criticism about the grading."
      -I am confused as well. If anything I probably am too generous in my scoring because I am such an av-geek and simply giddy being on the airplane that I don't take as much of a critical eye to the details. as some of the other flight reporters on this site. I don't know that I even take the approach of presenting a review rather I'm simply telling a story about an experience.

      Also, I want to thank you for the tips on formatting the images. I have been cropping the portrait images to "square" them,as you suggested, and the results are much better.

      Thanks again Kevin and happy flying.

      • Comment 439057 by
        KévinDC TEAM GOLD 4475 Comments

        I was going to say that if anything they’re a bit on the generous side but of course I totally get the AvGeekiness of it all. That plays in to it for me too.

        The fact that you tell a story is what makes your reports so interesting to read.

        Keep doing what you do so well!

  • Comment 439033 by
    Rewardflying GOLD 401 Comments

    Hi Christian, quite the brouhaha on this post. Interesting the peanut gallery doesn't take into consideration your 60+ (probably more as I'm guessing) first class reviews might allow you to be an expert when rating experiences, which you and Kevin correctly point out are subjective. It sounds like the peanut gallery just wants, good or bad. I too roll my eyes when seeing the "10s" across the board for an economy flight from Cleveland to Columbus. In my view the highest rating is never achieved, nor is the lowest rating of 1. Otherwise there isn't any wiggle room. The only time I'd give a 10 is if the question was: Did you land? And if not a 1 would be appropriate, assuming you were around to file a flight report. And looking at your ratings for this flight I'm not sure where the dissension is. ( I hope they don't read my reports)

    There are always dissenters but what's important is you are bringing a virtual experience to many who simply won't ever enjoy it. And you do it so well, with excellent photos and lively descriptions. Personally I enjoy your reports immensely and they motivate me for wanting to try these experiences. For example, I've never considered LH A340. Why would you? They have the 747-8 my favorites plane, the A380 my second favorite (sometimes my first) favorite plane and even the A350 my, hmm, favorite plane. The A340 is way down the list. But after reading this report it will be my next LH redemption.

    Happy reward flying Christian, back to finding that LH A340 FC redemption for me!

    • Comment 439056 by
      socalnow GOLD AUTHOR 737 Comments

      Hi Mark, thanks for the kind words and for helping me confirm that I haven't gone mad.

      "The only time I'd give a 10 is if the question was: Did you land? And if not a 1 would be appropriate, assuming you were around to file a flight report."
      -LOL! Come to think of it there aren't any reviews of OZ214 (for example) on the site.

      "There are always dissenters but what's important is you are bringing a virtual experience to many who simply won't ever enjoy it. And you do it so well, with excellent photos and lively descriptions. Personally I enjoy your reports immensely and they motivate me for wanting to try these experiences."
      -You're too kind.

      "The A340 is way down the list. But after reading this report it will be my next LH redemption."
      The F cabins are all virtually identical, in my experience. If you haven't done the F experience from MUC I recommend it wholeheartedly. With this flight I have completed the LH "F" set 747-400, 747-8i, A330, A340, and A380.

      Good luck with your search Mark. Happy flying.

      • Comment 439616 by
        Rewardflying GOLD 401 Comments

        Hi Christian, So miraculously there was a SQ25 to FRA Saver next week which I paired with LH.to PEK. Instead of taking the seat online I called to to hold as I didn't have enough points in the account. I gave the agent the route and she said SQ25 wasn't available. She didn't speak very good english so thought she made a mistake. But I refreshed my screen at it was gone! Someone took it what I was on the phone with them. Guess it wasn't meant to be.

        • Comment 439666 by
          socalnow GOLD AUTHOR 737 Comments

          First of all, it wasn't me! That's a bummer Mark. What are the odds? Did she let you wait list? I've had them allow me to wait list and hold the Star space with the caveat that it could be yanked back by the operating carrier at any time. At least you didn't transfer the points and then find the space was gone... You win some and you lose some, eh?

  • Comment 439058 by
    757Fan 462 Comments

    Wow, amazing report! Lufthansa F always looks amazing and truly one of the best F cabins in the skies.

    Thank you for sharing.

  • Comment 439061 by
    jetsetpanda SILVER 2279 Comments

    Hi Christian,

    Always a treat to come across one of your well written and superbly photographed FR's.

    "This lounge is just adjacent to my departure gate but, wory not, I'll make the trip out to the Satellite lounge as well."
    - Awfully nice of you to review both lounges for this audience. I'm sure your "sacrifice" is greatly appreciated by some.

    "There are different snacks in MUC."
    - They seem more enticing and better presented IMHO.

    "Each table was adorned with pretzels hung from antlers."
    - Shabby chic?

    "could not get past the schweinefleisch: crispy suckling pig"
    - Nothing like crispy pork rinds (or chicharron) as I call it. :P

    " I am warmly and promptly welcomed and informed that the cabin is all mine tonight. This could be a very memorable flight indeed, depending on the crew. Spoiler alert, they were fantastic."
    - That alone would have merited a "10" in my book, but this is your FR told from your individual perspective so only you can judged. ;) I have also been fortunate to experience an empty F cabin all for myself when I flew LH FRA-TLV in a 744. A memorable experience indeed.

    "A bit of an odd amenities kit."
    - I agree with you that is not quite compelling. I got my Rimowa one when I flew LH F and couldn't be happier.

    "I was somewhat surprised that they setup the entire cart with all the trimmings."
    - They did that for me too. I personally think that the cart adds flair to the service in F and if they do that for even 1 pax then kudos to LH.

    Meals look great except for the fish which you did not care for and indeed that presentation could have been better.

    Thanks for taking us along. You are one of the few members whose expertise and knowledge are assets to this site.

    • Comment 439065 by
      socalnow GOLD AUTHOR 737 Comments

      Great to hear from you Jetsetpanda and thanks for the feedback.

      "They seem more enticing and better presented IMHO."
      -I agree. Lots of nuts and dried fruits in FRA. And the gummy bears...that I do not understand.

      "Shabby chic?"
      -I rather enjoy the mountain lodge theme. Bavarian touches.

      "Nothing like crispy pork rinds (or chicharron) as I call it. :P"
      -Si, muy delicioso! Unfortunately these German chicharron was more towards chewy than crispy.

      "That alone would have merited a "10" in my book, but this is your FR told from your individual perspective so only you can judged. ;) "
      -OK, let's not start that up again. :) Well played...

      "I agree with you that is not quite compelling. I got my Rimowa one when I flew LH F and couldn't be happier."
      -Rimowa > Jill Sander.

      "They did that for me too. I personally think that the cart adds flair to the service in F and if they do that for even 1 pax then kudos to LH."
      -I concur completely. I was very pleased and touched at this level of attention.

      "You are one of the few members whose expertise and knowledge are assets to this site."
      -Go on. Seriously, that's a very kind sentiment. Thank you.

      Happy flying Jetsetpanda.

Login to post a comment.