Review of Shanghai Airlines flight Shanghai Xiangfan in Economy

Airline Shanghai Airlines
Flight FM9367
Class Economy
Seat 7D
Flight time 02:05
Take-off 03 Jul 10, 08:00
Arrival at 03 Jul 10, 10:05
FM 28 reviews
marathon
By GOLD 3420
Published on 2nd January 2014
(This is another oldie, one of my first flight reports posted in Month Four of Flight Report's existence. The standards are much higher now that FR nears its third birthday, and I completely reworded and expanded the French version to triple the original size.)

This FR starts very early on Saturday morning after a business trip to Shanghai, as I had decided to make a detour instead of flying back directly to Beijing.

Plane spotting was limited to this DL 747 that morning, but this was definitely not the plane that I was going to board.

photo P1010817a

It was no surprise to be bussed to a remote parking spot, next to the pusher. It has a green registration plate, like all vehicles operating in a closed perimeter (like an airport, a national park, a golf course…), and registered 民航 (public airport).

photo P1010818a

Other service vehicles on the other side :

photo P1010823a

Did you notice the (Taiwanese) Eva Air plane taking off in the background ? There were still very few direct flights between Mainland China and Taiwan, back in 2010.

And more unusual ones, which appear to be autonomous power supply trucks.

photo P1010820a

The daily flight from PVG was operated with a CRJ-200, a 50-seater jet which is the smallest jet that I ever boarded.

photo 5547094256_a698f6c11f_b

Take off; this is the limit of the airport

photo P1010830aphoto P1010831a

and some views of the plains west of Shanghai

photo P1010834a

A close up of that golf course which has more rivers than strictly needed

photo P1010835a

Other suburbs

photo P1010837a

Shanghai Hongqiao Airport (SHA), from a distance

photo P1010844a

A power conversion plant in the countryside

photo P1010849a

Nothing special about this flight, apart from it being full. I have no recollection of the meal served on board, but it must have been quite ordinary, since most Chinese domestic flights look very much alike in this regard. I do remember that the windows were too low (see the heads on the left), a commonly reported design error of that otherwise cosy aircraft.

photo 5546514909_3a045e1c60_b

An interesting page in the in flight magazine : what document can replace your (Chinese) ID to board a domestic flight ?

photo P1010828a

The answer, in short, is: your residence permit, your work permit, your student or military ID. HK and Macau residents certificates, so-called Taiwan Compatriot travel permits (台胞证) (issued by Mainland China). Taiwanese passports are not mentioned; it would even be illegal by Chinese law to mention them by name, since that would imply that Taiwan is not a Chinese territory. You can read here (in French) what happens if you try to connect in Mainland China with a Taiwanese passport (thank you Olrik for posting your FR just after mine to illustrate it :)

The blond and rather untidy guy illustrates that resident foreigners whose passport is being held (for six working days) for visa renewal receive an official certificate which allows them to travel in the country, but it is public expat knowledge that you can be denied boarding with such a document, and this happened to a colleague of mine.

Landing in Xiangfan and there was no doubt that it was both remote and tiny:

- So tiny that none of my tour books mentioned that it exists
- So tiny that www.elong.net, one of Mainland China's two major online travel agents, did not know that it exists
- So tiny that none of my Chinese colleagues ever landed there
- So tiny that all wondered why I would want to go there on a week-end
-So tiny that it does not have jet bridges or a taxiway

photo 5547095390_87180f1c0a_b

The fuel truck was already there as the passengers disembark.

photo 5546515673_25fb9f112e_b

The luggage handlers of Xiangfan were not overworked either. Although the plane was full, there were really not that a lot of luggage here on the left.

photo 5546517813_bbe7147d1d_b

Good thing, because you see here the entire luggage delivery room.

photo 5547096624_c7e4fd58b5_b

Sure, the guy who wrote about it in Wikipedia, maybe a local tourist office employee, does not hesitate to write that Xingfan is linked to major airports, such as Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou. The expression such as means that the list is not complete, which is stricly corrrect, for this is the exhaustive list of flights that day, posted at the check-in.

photo 5547099426_9d75060c06_b

Note that since I landed in the morning from PVG, and left the next day by Flight CA1386 to PEK, I took 50% ot the routes serving that airport. Xiangfan's control tower is obviously not overloaded with work, and actually has a looong lunch break, between the departure of the flight to PVG and the first evening flight.

The plane from Guangzhou was an ERJ145, also a 50 seater jet, seen here the next day in the evening.

photo 5547149058_2f5e8a6c46_b

I did not see the plane from Shenzhen; the aircraft to Beijing is that aging B737-300, here after landing in PEK.

photo 5547149654_a2ab932f02_b

At the terminal's landside exit, some taxi drivers rushed toward me, but they did not have a chance: the shuttle bus to the town was a few meters away, and left just after I boarded it. These taxi drivers had tried their luck and lost: this was the only flight in the morning, and the next one landed after 8pm.

Now we are getting into the tourist bonus; Xiangfan's station is vastly bigger than its airport.

photo P1010857a

Inside, the waiting room is quite different too (in Mainland China, travelers have access to the platform only fifteen minutes before the train's arrival, which always creates a mess)

photo 5547098726_130ef73a54_b

It was a two hour train ride, with buy on board on a trolley like on a plane

photo P1010865a

And then a bus, reaching this so picturesque town

photo P1020050a

Wait, it is modern ! there is an internet café (网吧), where you can buy second hand computers (二手电脑) too.

photo P1020051a

And then a taxi to reach the gate of Wudangshan (武当山) National Park , which you may have never heard about, but is listed by Unesco in its World Heritage List.

photo P1020053a

… where I slept in this wonderful hotel. No, I had not made reservations, I knew that I would manage to find something

photo P1010946a

From the 15th century, the Chinese proved their mastership at hand cutting granite slabs, grating them for anti-skid purposes, and adjusting them into kilometers of stairs (on both axes). This feat is not what Wudangshan is famous for, although the ascent is not for weak of heart.

photo P1010981-3a

Wudangshan is primarily connected to wudang, a variant of kung fu which is performed with a weapon, but often in a slow manner much like taichihuan that you can see performed in city parks everywhere in China.

You probably got the point that Wudangshan is not very easy to reach, but I was surprised by the number of foreign visitors, mostly in their late 20's – early 30's, and obviously in excellent shape, since they had come to visit the source of their favorite martial art. One of them performed a spectacular demonstration with a wooden stick, while a monk corrected a student here on the right.

photo P1010927a

This show was for (Chinese) tourists, but its choreography was nevertheless impressively flawless.

photo P1010903a

There were enough swords in the souvenir shops to equip an army, but they probably did not have the same magic properties of Destiny, the sword of Li Mubai which is stolen by a female adventurer in Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon, whose final scene was shot in Wudangshan.

photo P1010951a

I did not need a sword, and I had already climbed dozens of kilometers of granite stairs in China, so my real goal was the Gold Temple, at the top of the mountain overlooking a spectacular landscape.

photo P1010892a

The weather which had been excellent the day before was unfortunately more like the misty settings of the movie.

photo P1010998a

The visibility was little more than a hundred meters,

photo P1010991a

…and I had to do with the temples located further down.

photo P1010874 pano aphoto P1010908aphoto P1010936a

The way back to modernity was similar, only that Wudangshan's train station waiting room was much smaller. But you had to sit on the seats reserved for your train, identified by the blue signs overhead.

photo P1020057a

And of course wait until Train T6774 to Wuchang (武昌) was nearing the station to be allowed on the platform.

photo P1020064aphoto P1020074a

3+3 seating is tight, but sometimes, you can get lucky and have no neighbors. Riding a Chinese trains is really not that different from flying.

photo P1020082a

… since there was buy on board too, including miscellaneous toys and toiletry supplies.

photo P1020088a

Since I knew there would be nothing at the airport, I took dinner at this world class restaurant next to the station.

photo P1020102a

快餐厅 means fast restaurant : it was as fast as your favorite airport lounge, and with more food than in that of many major airlines.

photo P1020101a

This kind of traveling might not have been your cup of tea, but this was another great week-end !
See more

Verdict

Shanghai Airlines

8.0/10
Cabin9.0
Cabin crew9.0
Entertainment/wifi6.0
Meal/catering8.0

Shanghai - PVG

9.5/10
Efficiency10.0
Access8.0
Services10.0
Cleanliness10.0

Xiangfan - XFN

8.5/10
Efficiency10.0
Access8.0
Services8.0
Cleanliness8.0

Conclusion

From Shanghai, I had the choice between
- this single daily flight, with the non-discountable fare of 1080 RMB + 90 RMB web travel agency fee
- or Train K149, departing from Shanghai South station at 8:49, and reaching Xiangfan station at 18:47, for a modest 106 RMB

It was ten times more expensive, but I did not regret taking the first option.

Related

4 Comments

  • Comment 96472 by
    KévinDC TEAM SILVER 5304 Comments

    Lucky that you took off from Shanghai on a relatively smog-free day. It seems that in most reports Shanghai is always envelopped in clounds and smog. It seems odd to see a CRJ-200 or any 50-seater on Chinese domestic flights where we so often see widebodies for short routes. But I guess it makes sense that some routes can't support mainline, especially to smaller remote communities. Nice bonus pics...gives a detailed impression of the real mainland China outside the big cities. Thanks for sharing!

    • Comment 286157 by
      marathon GOLD AUTHOR 9566 Comments

      You would not believe the number of secondary lines serving lesser Chinese cities that no foreigner would consider visiting. You apparently missed my TYN-KWE report on China Express, which was then an all CRJ200 Chinese airline (OK, they only had 4 aircraft. Wow, they now have six CRJ900, too! Such a dramatic expansion anywhere in China^^). I added a bonus in the English version of TYN-KWE.
      Yes, I experienced poor visibility in PVG each time I flew in or out. Thanks for your comment !

  • Comment 132549 by
    Mathieu 2087 Comments

    Hi François,

    I'm wasting my time on Flight Report... And I found your Flight Report. Thank you very much.

    The bonus is more interesting than the flight itself. Normal flight, normal jet. What about the catering ?

    CRJ200 is the smaller jet you've ever boarded ? You should experience the small Jetstream 41 between Lyon & Lorient ahah (I experience them every month).

    What a nice bonus, axed on the chinese railway network. I love to discover other ways to travel, especially in other country. I'm fed up of french TGV !

    Thanks a lot,

    Mathieu.

    Ps : C'est vrai que j'aurais pu écrire en français, je voulais simplement m'amuser.

    • Comment 312965 by
      marathon GOLD AUTHOR 9566 Comments

      Hi Mathieu,

      This was an archive report, so I did not have many pictures. This being a rather short and early flight, my educated guess is that the catering was limited to a pastry and orange juice.
      The Jetstream 41 is not a jet, but a turboprop, and I flew in an even smaller aircraft. You may be interested in my series of flights on Taiwanese Do-228, starting with TTT - GNI, to islands which seldom receive visitors. They have an English version too, for your reading convenience. :)

      Merci pour d'avoir apporté un second commentaire à ce FR ! cela m'a amusé de répondre en anglais. ^^

Login to post a comment.