Review of Shanghai Airlines flight Yinchuan Xi'an in Economy

Airline Shanghai Airlines
Flight FM9206
Class Economy
Seat 7F
Aircraft Boeing 737-800
Flight time 01:10
Take-off 23 Jun 10, 19:05
Arrival at 23 Jun 10, 20:15
FM   #46 out of 142 Airlines A minimum of 20 Flight-Reports is required in order to appear in the rankings. 28 reviews
marathon
By GOLD 2344
Published on 2nd February 2014
(This is an expanded version of the original FR posted in French here)

Who ever heard of the Chinese province of Ningxia, which is dealt with in ten pages in my 1,033 page Lonely Planet tour book? Located in an oasis in desert territory with a rather hostile weather, Yinchuan is definitely off the beaten track.

photo P1010046a

The purpose of this detour on a business trip to Xi'an were the ruins of the mysterious Western Xia civilization annihilated in 1227 by the Mongols under orders of Genghis Khan, in what may be the first historically recorded ethnocide.

photo P1010101 panoaphoto P1010088a

These dried earth pyramids stand in the desert. There are only a handful of visitors, and no public transportation to these archeological sites.

photo P1010093a

The noisier visitors are these military helicopters – the military love these empty spaces away from any prying eyes.

photo P1010114a

Yinchuan is another Chinese city above the million inhabitant mark (yawn),

photo P1010217 panoa

but like all provincial capitals in China, it has a commendable provincial museum, well worth a lengthy visit, especially if you skip the regulatory 25% of space devoted to the glorious local history of the Communist party (they had a hard time filling their quota in this one).

photo P1010141a

The cheap motel where I stayed was nondescript, apart from these surviving Chinglish signs in the toilets.

photo P1010043bcd

On the other hand, the Yellow River, which takes its name from the billion tonnes of sand ripped off the Gobi desert yearly and gives its sandy color, is not much of an attraction. Like the Nile in Upper Egypt, it hardly irrigates anything there, and moreover is not navigable. You cross it to go to the airport on the right bank, whereas Yinchuan is on the left bank, not even alongside the bank since the river is next to useless there.

image

The list of departing flights illustrates the exoticism of the location. Why two flights to 乌鲁木齐 (URC = Urumqi, transcribed in Wulumuqi by Chinese who have a hard time with Uighur phonetics)?

photo P1010229-31

This is because Ningxia like Xinjiang is a Muslim province, which creates links. The mosques of Yinchuan are a minor tourist attraction.

photo P1010190a

This is the prayer room, with a veil shielding the women's section on the left.

photo P1010197a

Shanghai Airlines seems to be used to domestic flights with stopovers : Flight FM9384 is bound to Zhengzhou 郑州 by way (Shanghai) Hongqiao 红桥, i.e. a INC-CGO-SHA service, while my flight FM9206 to Xi'an 西安 continues to (Shanghai) Pudong 浦东, i.e; an INC-XIY-PVG service. Frequent Readers of Flight Report are of course familiar with all these Chinese cities and would place them on a map without hesitation; I insert a map produced with the help of gcmap.com for newbies :-)

photo gcmap flights INC-Shanghai

My plane is not this B737-800 with winglets, but another one without. What I found interesting is outside: the tarmac is wet from downpour two hours earlier, because a desert does not need to be a place where it never rains, but can also be a place there the annual rainfall is limited, and falls in an irregular manner.

image

Is that because of the rain? The plane leaves its parking stand twenty minute late. It will not be on time in Xi'an, by less than ten minutes.

photo P1010234a

image

There is only a small biturboprop on the tarmac, but this is not the last flight of the day: there will be four more coming and departing in the evening.

image

Take-off towards the southwest, alongside the Yellow River. With the contre-jour through a less than clean window, my pictures are not very good, but this is the side with a view on the Yellow River, which is the most interesting feature during that phase of the flight.

photo P1010236aphoto P1010236a

The plane then quickly turns towards the south-east, over the deserts of Ningxia and Shaanxi. It is nearly the summer solstice, but the night is early in China which like most Asian countries does not have a daylight savings time.

imageimage

I have no memory of the dinner, which must have been very ordinary, by Chinese domestic standards.
See more

Verdict

Shanghai Airlines

7.8/10
Cabin8.0
Cabin crew8.0
Entertainment/wifi7.0
Meal/catering8.0

Yinchuan - INC

8.8/10
Efficiency10.0
Access7.0
Services8.0
Cleanliness10.0

Xi'an - XIY

8.5/10
Efficiency10.0
Access8.0
Services8.0
Cleanliness8.0

Conclusion

The Yinchuan – Xi'an flight had two interesting peculiarities:

First this view on the Yellow River whose shallow stream there makes it difficult to realize that some of its floods caused millions of deaths some two thousand kilometers downstream.

And then particularly attractive fares, which were then as low as 120 RMB if booked early, and typically 240 RMB at the last moment... if you really want to go there, and few visitors do.

Related

3 Comments

  • Comment 98589 by
    NGen92 55 Comments

    Thanks for sharing your travel experience in this interior province.

    Very amazing to see that city and most tourist attraction sites (museum, mosques, etc.) seems to be empty and very quiet compare with other chinese cities... Is it located within a military zone?

    • Comment 287505 by
      marathon GOLD AUTHOR 9561 Comments

      There are military areas around Yinchuan, but the main reason for having so few people outside was simply the temperature. Yinchuan is at the edge of the Gobi desert, very cold in winter and very hot in summer : the maximum temperature that day was 34°C. Thanks for your comment !

  • Comment 98608 by
    jetsetpanda 2294 Comments

    Thanks for sharing this interesting FR and exposing us to these seldom explored corners of China.

Login to post a comment.