Review of Air China flight Xi'an Beijing in Economy

Airline Air China
Flight CA1232
Class Economy
Seat 11A
Aircraft Airbus A320
Flight time 02:05
Take-off 14 Jun 15, 11:00
Arrival at 14 Jun 15, 13:05
CA 186 reviews
marathon
By GOLD 1702
Published on 27th January 2016
This is another flight in a trip for mixed private and business purposes. I already reported some of them:

CGO - PEK: CA1326 (B738) MiG Alley
CKG - CGQ : CZ6460 (A321) Roughing it in Changchun
CGQ - TAO : CZ3938 (A321) The Germans’ Chinese Riviera
TAO - CAN : SC4675 (B738) We regret to announce that Flight SC4675…

Xi’an is famous mostly for its terracotta army dating back from the 2nd century BC, but this is not the only major tourist spot there. You will have to wait until the bonus of this FR to discover another one, and you will have to wait for a long time, because I had better warn you that this FR is shamefully long, and so is its bonus. Better first go and help yourself with a mug of coffee, preferably better than that served on an Air China domestic flight, before reading on.

Xi’an kept its 14th century walls, adapting its gates to the constraints of modern road traffic), and if you enjoy jogging, you can run around the entire old city for a 13.7 km warm up. I’ll only show you one of the gates and its defending fortress, as seen from the ring expressway from the taxi driving me to the airport.

photo IMG_8607a

The toll gate at the airport exit (identified in big characters: 机场) is inevitably decorated with reminiscences of the city walls.

photo IMG_8612a

XIY is served by many airlines: better be a fast reader to identify your terminal

photo IMG_8613a

I do not remember which terminal this was, but the driver did not make a mistake

photo IMG_8614a

The terminal is in view

photo IMG_8618a

What is this small space painted in yellow outside the terminal?

photo IMG_8621a

It is written on the pole: this is the smoking area!

photo IMG_8620a

Yes, the entire smoking area outside the terminal is now limited to a few square feet around two poles like this one!

photo IMG_8622a

Since I do not smoke, I did not use this minimalist infrastructure and entered in the terminal. There could have been an explosive detection test, but they were probably doing random checks and I was not stopped.

photo IMG_8646a

Where is the check in counter for my flight to Beijing?

photo IMG_8623a

Counter 34? OK, let’s go.

photo IMG_8624a

There are automated BP dispensing machines, but I did not try them.

photo IMG_8645a

It does not show on this picture…

photo IMG_8626a

… but the line is moderate at Counter #34

photo IMG_8627a

What is strange is that the passengers before me are being processed even though there is a “Closed position” sign

photo IMG_8639a

And when my turn comes, I am told that no, I should take the lien to Counter #35. I did not quite understand, but all passengers being processed at Counter #34 had a BP in hand
photo IMG_8631a

Maybe Counter #34 actually processes « international transfers » (landside), like Counter #33? It remains a mystery for me.

photo IMG_8633a

There is a longer line at Counter #35, but this is no big deal: things progress quite fast.

photo IMG_8636a

My luggage reaches the scale

photo IMG_8640a

… and after pronounced the magic words: 我要窗边位子 (I want a window seat), I receive a seat with an unequivocal window.

photo IMG_9100a

This piece of clothing has become a thing of the past in urban China: this young boy held by his mother wears pants with a slit behind, so that it is not necessary to remove it for defecating…

photo IMG_8643aphoto IMG_8644a

Not much waiting at the security check access

photo IMG_8647a

… under this FIDS where my flight is announced to be on time

photo IMG_8648a

A local curiosity: signs in the waiting lines area remind with cartoon drawings the various safety constraints. No need to translate them for you: all Flight Report readers will understand each of them.

photo IMG_8649aphoto IMG_8650aphoto IMG_8653a

The last one has to do with the restrictions on power banks above the 100 / 160 Wh; this is the only one where the passenger does not seem very happy.

photo IMG_8654a

With one exception (I forgot where), body search was systematic at the security check during that trip, no matter if the metal detector had beeped or not. I do not know if this reinforcement of security measures if temporary, or if there is an official reason for it (the Chinese authorities seldom explain why they reinforce security when they do, anyway).

Anyway, I am now airside

photo IMG_8655a

XIY is not a very plane-spotter friendly airport, because few windows are accessible; on the other hand, they are not smeared by the rain due to their incline. I wiggle my way to this location next to Gate 12.

photo IMG_8665a

… in order to reach this narrow place that a Chinese plane spotter has already found before me

photo IMG_8659a

A Shenzhen Airlines 738; there are many in China

photo IMG_8656a

Less usual, a Tianjin Airlines E-190

photo IMG_8658a

Even less unusual, a Qingdao Airlines A320

photo IMG_8664a

An obviously local airline: Chang’an 长安 is the ancient name of Xi’an, at the time when this was the Tang Dynasty’s capital. That is where the name of Beijing’s Chang’an Avenue (between the Forbidden City and Tian’anmen Square) comes from.

photo IMG_8672a

It is already time for boarding, but since I am travelling alone, I can keep taking pictures until the last moment.

photo IMG_8668a

This is the A320 operating my flight

photo IMG_8670a

For plane registration number geeks

photo IMG_8671a

Note the pigtails on the silhouette of the woman on the toilets’ pictogram!

photo IMG_8673a

Now that I have exhausted all the resources of the terminal, it is time for me to take this jet bridge with windows.

photo IMG_8677aphoto IMG_8680a

We find again Chang’an in the name of the company which bought advertising space here.

photo IMG_8681a

Xiamen Airlines 738 parked at the next gate

photo IMG_8682a

A minor jam at the entrance of the plane.

photo IMG_8684a

This is not a refined way of presenting them, but there is a pile of copies of the China Daily at the end of the jet bridge. The China Daily is one of China’s English language major daily newspapers. It is of course under government control and impeccably politically correct, but not as nationalistic (and sometimes xenophobic) as the Global Times.

photo IMG_8685a

Traditional view from the extremity of the jet bridge

photo IMG_8686a

The J cabin, with as usual 2 rows in a 2+2 layout.

photo IMG_8687a

This time, I am seated in the first row of the Economy cabin, which has an exceptional seat pitch. That is when realize that I left my measuring tape in my checked luggage, and I use my copy of the China Daily as a makeshift tool: 55 cm.

photo IMG_8689a

That leaves ample space for the legs. The only problem is that there is no space for your hand luggage, but I managed to place my laptop case under the neighboring seat, because it was empty and the passenger behind did not have any stuff to put there.

photo IMG_8690a

When you have LCC-compatible legs, there is no problem

photo IMG_8693a

Is it safer to hold your kid in your arms in case of turbulence?

photo IMG_8748a

The overhead lights

photo IMG_8699a

The safety card, both sides

photo IMG_8691aphoto IMG_8692a

Air China’s route network in the in-flight magazine.

photo IMG_8694a

Contrary to CZ, CA identifies separately domestic, regional (Hong-Kong and Macau) and Taiwan flights, respectively, leaving in the shade the exact category of the latter.

photo IMG_8695a

On the other hand, CA could not avoid including the South China Sea in the map: it is irrelevant for its air routes, but Chinese law has stiff fines for publishing maps of China which do not represent the entire territory, including all its claims on land and sea. This is the probable reason why you cannot buy a new copy of the Lonely Planet guide on China in that country: the map which appears in the first pages is illegal (you can find second hand copies left by travelers, though).

photo IMG_8696a

The international route map is interesting too: there are flights to Europe and North America, but none to Africa.

photo IMG_8697a

And only one reaching South America, in continuation of a flight to MAD

photo IMG_8698a

The planes parked at the terminal:

photo IMG_8703a

This aircraft is really from her hub: Kunming is the capital of Yunnan Province, in the extreme south of China.

photo IMG_8705a

A more commonplace CZ A320

photo IMG_8713a

Dornier 328-300 Jet belonging to Hainan Airlines.

photo IMG_8715a

An A330 belonging to I-Fly, a Russian charter airline

photo IMG_8708a

Take-off is right on time

photo IMG_8718a

This viaduct crossing a valley: a high speed line?

photo IMG_8724aphoto IMG_8727a

No, a future tollway, because there is future rest area here

photo IMG_8728aphoto IMG_8729a

Tollway exits and toll gates of a standard design, later

photo IMG_8732aphoto IMG_8736a

The countryside is still very dry

photo IMG_8731a

Low quality headphone are distributed

photo IMG_8740a

… but the only audio channel is that of the IFE’s program

photo IMG_8742aphoto IMG_8761a

Distribution of the catering

photo IMG_8743a

The catering is not what you would want to board this flight: you only get this small sandwich and a drink.

photo IMG_8745a

The coffee… is Air China coffee: not very good, but could be worse

photo IMG_8747a

The sandwich is a Chinese kind that I had already tasted and which I found quite stodgy. A coffee, even one provided by Air China, was useful to help eating it.

photo IMG_8746a

A reservoir that I have not identified

photo IMG_8749a

Air to air with a Sichuan Airlines A32x with sharklets

photo IMG_8755a

She was going to turn towards the north when I saw her

photo IMG_8756a

The plane reaches the Henan and Hebei plains somewhere near the border between these two provinces.

photo IMG_8757a

This countryside is both very fertile and heavily populated: see the density of the villages there!

photo IMG_8758a

A PLA (People’s Liberation Air force) airbase near Dingxing 定兴

photo IMG_8765-2aphoto IMG_8767a

On the other hand, this looked somewhat like an airfield from a distance, but it appears to be nothing but fields.

photo IMG_8777aphoto IMG_8778a

Again the Chinese countryside, again heavily populated when it is fertile. In the distance, towards the left, there is an airstrip located next to Gaobedian.

photo IMG_8781a

I spent hours on Google Earth looking in the wrong places, until I found this airfield with a rather unusual layout, in Zhuozhou 涿州, some 130 km south-south-west from PEK and 32 minutes before landing. That is how I managed to reconstitute the route I took on this part of the flight.

photo IMG_8785a

Two identical and rather short runways and taxiways, inside a perfectly circular perimeter. There is nearly no building; my best hypothesis is that this is a sky-diving field, but I found no confirmation after limited research on Chinese websites.

photo IMG_8786a

The plane follows a rather unexpected route, flying north beyond PEK to turn then south and line up with one of the 18x runways. The Hebei plain where Beijing is located is surrounded with small mountains, crisscrossed with winding roads,

photo IMG_8791a

… and with rather deep valleys

photo IMG_8795a

This unexpected route provides me the opportunity of a spectacular view. This raw picture is not very legible,

photo IMG_8799-2a

… but look once it has been processed: the zigzagging line on the crests is no other than the Ming Dynasty Great Wall. This section is probably located just north of Lake Zhenzhu’s leisure resort.

photo IMG_8799a

But this is not over, because beyond Guanting Reservoir 官厅水库

photo IMG_8804a

… and the mixed civilian / military Yongning 永宁 airfield and slightly upstream from this reservoir

photo IMG_8810a

… we see again the mountains of the northern edge of Hebei Province

photo IMG_8817a

… and again the Great Wall, in a rough landscape, here in natural colors

photo IMG_8819a

… and after color enhancing to make it more visible

photo IMG_8819-2aphoto IMG_8821a

The most extraordinary view to my eyes – maybe not to those of my readers – is this one:

photo IMG_8824a

I thought I recognized the Great Wall site of Simatai, which has the peculiarity of the Wall crossing a valley where there is an artificial lake behind a dam built later. I first saw the Great Wall when hiking on it from Jinshanling to Simatai, which was the fulfillment of a dream which I believed to be impossible when I was a kid, because China was so remote and inaccessible at the time.

photo IMG_8827a

Having the impression of seeing again Simatai from above made me feel again the emotion of being in a place which I had thought to be forever out of reach.

photo IMG_8825a

I was actually wrong ; after a long and tedious research to identify the above mentioned air strips, I realized this was really the Great Wall site of Huanghua 黄花 where I have never had a chance to go. This name means « Yellow Flowers » because these mountains are covered with yellow flowers in the spring, according to a Chinese colleague from a time I was stationed in Beijing.

photo IMG_8834a

Maybe one day, I’ll go to Huanghua. Now that I have seen it from above, this section looks worth it too…

photo IMG_8832a

This childhood memory vanishes with the landscape, as the plane enters the Hebei plain, heading towards the airport.

photo IMG_8836a

Huairou’s reservoir

photo IMG_8837a

Huairou is the city where you should go by bus from Beijing to reach some of the best (and least visited) Great Wall sites.

photo IMG_8840a

Final descent

photo IMG_8844a

The expressway and the Airport Express line which serves the Dongzhimen – Sanyuanqiao – T3 – T2 route.

photo IMG_8848a

We are close to landing, with an aircraft waiting next to the runway threshold

photo IMG_8852a

Not much wind, according to this windsock. The flight time is 2h05’ according to the schedule, but only lasted 1h32’ from takeoff to touch down.

photo IMG_8854aphoto IMG_8859a

Cargo aircraft: SF Airlines,

photo IMG_8861a

Grandstar Cargo,

photo IMG_8918a

… and EMS (the Chinese Post)

photo IMG_8862a

A Hainan Airlines 787 in front of an A330-300

photo IMG_8872a

Hainan Airlines 333

photo IMG_8875a

MU A321, in the old livery

photo IMG_8876a

Two Falcon 7X

photo IMG_8877a

A Gulfstream G200 (B-8139) in the foreground

photo IMG_8880a

A rarity: a Turkmenistan Airlines aircraft. The only few flight reports posted on this airline were in French. Any English speaking volunteers?

photo IMG_8885a

A Capital Airlines A320 with sharklets. Five years ago, when I flew with them, this airline’s largest aircraft were CRJ-200. Times, they are a-changin’.

photo IMG_8887a

Terminal 3C, for domestic flights, and also the only passenger access to/from landside, by road or rail.

photo IMG_8889a

Terminal 3D is domestic too, but it is separated from the two main terminal buildings by taxiways

photo IMG_8893a

A Tibet Airlines A319 leaves her parking space,

photo IMG_8895a

… taxiing to the runway …

photo IMG_8902a

… and takes off soon afterwards. She is not flying to Lhasa directly, but will stop over in CTU or CKG, the two gateways to Tibet.

photo IMG_8928a

A general view of Terminal 3, with the domestic and international terminals

photo IMG_8905aphoto IMG_8907a

I had lots of trouble getting an acceptable (?) picture of this one in the distance, but did not identify her.

photo IMG_8915a

A CZ A321 takes off

photo IMG_8920a

The jetbridge approaches

photo IMG_8931a

An Air China 737 in flowered livery 737

photo IMG_8933a

Air China A321

photo IMG_8934a

A Sichuan Airlines A320 takes off

photo IMG_8936a

Going up to the Arrivals level

photo IMG_8937aphoto IMG_8942a

A last look at the aircraft which brought me here

photo IMG_8943a

A « blue flower livery » CA A330 CA

photo IMG_8947aphoto IMG_8948a

A CZ A380 in the distance

photo IMG_8949a

Water fountains are everywhere in Chinese airports

photo IMG_8953a

What about the toilets? Yes, they are clean,

photo IMG_8956a

… with a flower decoration too.

photo IMG_8954a

They are targeting a five star award, but that seems ambitious to me.

photo IMG_8955a

The flows towards the arrivals and the transfers separate here

photo IMG_8957a

… going through empty boarding rooms

photo IMG_8958a

But whether PEK is your final destination or not, when your plane arrived at Terminal 3D, you cannot avoid a bus transfer which is the only way out of it.

photo IMG_8960a

Plane spotting opportunities are few on the way: a CA A321 in standard livery

photo IMG_8964a

.. and another one in ocean livery. There is an ANA aircraft tail behind.

photo IMG_8965a

Not much more to be seen during the short bus transfer

photo IMG_8970a

… apart from an outside view of this terminal 3D, which basically spells bad luck when you disembark there from a domestic flight.

photo IMG_8971a

A longish walk in the domestic terminal. It is 13:05, i.e. my flight’s ETA.

photo IMG_8975a

Arrival in the luggage delivery room

photo IMG_8979a

All told, 35 minutes elapsed from the arrival at the jet-bridge and the delivery of my luggage, including the bus transfer : this is not a very good performance by Chinese standards.

photo IMG_8989a

After leaving the luggage delivery area, but before reaching landside proper, there is a table with a small tray.

photo IMG_8991a

This tray contains some lighters which had been abandoned at the security check upstairs by passengers. You can thus replace the one you could not fly with, but there is not much choice today.

photo IMG_8992a

Waiting is as usual negligible at the taxi stand; what takes the longest time is reaching it, because you have the choice between undersized lifts where there is a waiting time, and very long travellators going down, or stairs. Nine minutes elapsed since the arrival landside.

photo IMG_8999a

Arrival of a CA 737, seen just before leaving the airport perimeter.

photo IMG_9002a

There were some traffic jams as usual between the 5th and 4th ring roads. This olivgreen car which slaloms between the traffic lanes has a number plate with black characters off a white background, like all official vehicles, such as those of the army and police.

photo IMG_9006a

Its driver of course doesn’t feel constrained by this recommendation not to drive on the emergency lane.

photo IMG_9007a

I wonder what this Justice Department (法司) car registered in Xinjiang Province was doing there… Ürümqi is 3,200 km away from Beijing on Expressway G30!

photo IMG_9009a

We are already leaving the air travel topic of this report. What follows is a long bonus on a first rate tourist site located outside Xi’an. No, not the world famous terracotta army, but Huashan, one of the five sacred mountains of Chinese Taoism, and by far the most famous of them.

Xi’an now has two subways lines (more to come), with Line 1 ending at Xi’an’s North Railway station, built in the outskirts of the city on the Zhengxi (= Zhengzhou – Xi’an) high speed line. The next stop is Huashan-North, 40 minutes away.
My business trip is organized with little more than a day advance warning, so I could buy train tickets ahead of time, but I have checked that there is ample space on the 7:53 train out of Xi’an North station.

I make it quite early to the station; not a bad idea, because there is longish line at the only manual counter for tickets sales.

photo IMG_8159a

The information display overhead lists the number of seats remaining on the next ten days for each train and seat category. No problem for me: with 91 empty seats in 1st class and 448 empty seats in 2nd class, the train is going to be very empty on that 13th June.

photo IMG_8158a

一张票到华山北 (One ticket to Huashan North) : little communication is needed, but the transaction takes more time than with a Chinese passenger, because I am not a Chinese citizen , and therefore I do not have a Chinese ID. In order to counter the black market in peak travel times (no Westerner can imagine what it means to have 1.3 billion Chinese travelling during Chinese New Year), train tickets are now nominative and must bear the name and ID number of the traveler. Issuing a ticket for a Chinese person is easy: the ticket clerk only needs to read the contactless chip of the ID card. But for a foreigner, you must type the name and the passport number, and foreigners always have improbably long and unpronounceable names.

photo IMG_8161a

I was not going to complicate matters further by paying with my credit card (but you saw that this was possible), the clerk typed my references with lightning professional efficiency and gave me back my passport, the change off a 100 yuan bill and the train ticket where I obscured my incomplete name which is unpronounceable and way too long for the maximum number of letters that the Chinese specify for this purpose in any official document.

photo IMG_8162a

Nobody checks that I have a passport matching the abridged but still improbably long and unpronounceable name on my ticket when I scan it at the turnstile.

photo IMG_8166a

Once « railside », if I may say, I go to this kiosk received a small bottle of water which is offered to each passenger. One bottle only: the staff ticks the ticket when giving the bottle.

photo IMG_8168a

I have no time for train spotting, which is not easy anyway, because I only have access to the platform where my train is. This is another identical one, seen while departing from the station.

photo IMG_8177a

Forty minutes by train plus a quarter of an hour by taxi later, I reached my destination, i.e. this temple which is the starting point of the main trail up Huashan.

photo IMG_8183a

The ticket (which is quite expensive by Chinese standards) is valid for two days, and in order to deter ticket resales, you must record a fingerprint for reentry purposes. It won’t be useful for me, since this will be a single day trip.

photo IMG_8194a

And that is the beginning of the ascent. In China, a trail up a sacred mountain is a solid construction made all the way of carefully cut granite slabs.

There are civic education signs along the way like this one

photo IMG_8202a
Respect the environment – Do not throw rubbish in the water streams

Since there are (admittedly few) foreigners, better translate in crude English the messages, in case they had not understood from the pictogram that throwing away a lit match is not a good idea.

photo IMG_8207a

Seeing this unique chinglish on that sign justified hiking up the mountain, rather than using one of the aerial tramways.

photo IMG_8208a

The second part of the message in Chinese actually means « Do not set fire to the entire household »

There are not only tourists on the trails up Huashan. All the souvenirs, the water, the food is carried up by often elderly men who carry loads up to 50 kg. I do not know if they also use the aerial trams for that purpose, after hours.

photo IMG_8204a

Apart from water and other drinks, you can find in these shops the padlocks that the Chinese love leaving behind them after engraving them with their names.

photo IMG_8210a

Climbing a sacred mountain in China means climbing granite steps. Lots of them. Most of the 1,800 m altitude gain is done on stairs, some reasonably easy like this one.

photo IMG_8213a

And others dramatically steep like that one

photo IMG_8236a

I had not brought my measuring tape, but see the width of the steps compared to the size of my shoes!

photo IMG_8238a

Once you reach the top, the visitor discovers razor sharp mountains on which temples have been built.

photo IMG_8262a

Many stairs have been hewn out of sheer rock

photo IMG_8315a

But here, a wooden staircase has been built to provide a way around a difficult section, since the last time I visited.

photo IMG_8272a

天梯 (« The Stairway to Heaven ») is the spectacular trail section from the North Peak to the South Peak of Huashan

photo IMG_8263aphoto IMG_8281a

During the ascension to Heaven

photo IMG_8288a

In the distance, the temples of the North Peak (on the left), and somewhat below, the upper station of the main cable car to Huashan, for the majority of visitors who do not climb on foot.

photo IMG_8289a

A sacred mountain is ideal place to leave vows ribbons. In order to facilitate the work of the gods, these ribbons are grouped according to the type of wishes: you have in the foreground the wishes of success at school exams, on the left wishes of a long life, and so on.

photo IMG_8323aphoto IMG_8326a

Another narrow peak of bare rock

photo IMG_8378a

… with stairs cut directly in the rock, seen here form the viewpoint in front of it

photo IMG_8379a

.. and on location

photo IMG_8333a

The legend is that this rock has been cut in two by a sword

photo IMG_8349a

This other spot has been privatized by a photographer.

photo IMG_8356a

This picture taking is without danger because both the visitor and photographer’s assistant who shows him typical poses are secured by a cable attached to a belt.

photo IMG_8363a

Since this is a sacred mountain, there are monasteries, but since they have to make a living, they provide hosteling (at hotel prices, but mountain refuge comfort)

photo IMG_8343a

And hot meals like this one

photo IMG_8338a

This standard food tray is sold 38 yuan: I ate more than that for 10 yuan in a food court in the center of Xi’an. This is in line with local prices: everything is four times more expensive, due to the logistics involved in getting it there.

photo IMG_8339a

Guess where I call you from? You can place such a call there on your cell phone because there are GSM relay antennas like this one, camouflaged as a pine tree which is credible from a distance.

photo IMG_8372a

The highest point of Huashan is the South Peak, 2,154 meters above sea level. It took me determination to manage to take a picture of an anonymous tourist without somebody in the way, and it was so crowded there was no way I could ask somebody to take me with my camera…

photo IMG_8393a

One of the most spectacular places in Huashan is at the far end of the site, and is only post signed in Chinese: 长空栈道 could be translated roughly by The Planks Trail in the Sky.

photo IMG_8403a

How could you call otherwise this vertiginous contraption that so many internet users have seen without knowing if the pictures had been doctored? There is no photoshopping involved: on this sheer quasi-vertical cliff, these precariously attached wooden boards on iron consoles had only chains to keep visitors from falling to their death (which they sometimes did).

photo Huashan 1a

But look again: in 2005, two steel cables have been installed and it is now forbidden to venture on this frightening trail without a safety harness, available for rent for 30 yuan (but you can bring your own, which I did on my first visit to Huashan)

photo Huashan 3

The harness removes all fear if you are not vertigo-prone (an admittedly big IF), and the landscape is just stupendous. The matters become trickier once you reached the tiny temple with a tiny platform at the far end, and when you then realize that this is a dead end you have no choice but backtrack and cross the other people on these really narrow boards facing this landscape:

photo IMG_8472 panoa

I did not go on the Planks Trail this time, because there was too much waiting time,

photo IMG_8436a

… and I wanted to have time to go this time to the Chessboard Pavilion.

photo IMG_8441a

How could I not want reach this lonely pavilion on a promontory?

photo IMG_8422a

All the more that few visitors venture there: I did not need to wait to take this picture.

photo IMG_8442a

First climb many stairs on the granite face

photo IMG_8438a

But then, you have to go down this narrow fault in the middle of the picture

photo IMG_8452a

A harness is compulsory there too, and being in good physical shape is recommended, because the steps and holds hewn in the rock are few and far in between.

photo IMG_8481a

In the good old times, there were of course only these iron chains to help. That was the cost for playing a game of chess on the stone chessboard in this very small pavilion.

photo IMG_8459a

Back towards the East peak, with a view on the plain below

photo IMG_8489a

The white bar at the end of the avenue is the new Huashan North high speed train station.

photo IMG_8490a

Visiting Huashan requires some effort, but when the weather is good (and I was lucky to have blue skies each time), the visitor is rewarded with spectacular vistas. I hope that you liked this landscape; thanks for reading me and see you soon on the Planks Trail or for a game of chess!
See more

Verdict

Air China

7.8/10
Cabin9.0
Cabin crew8.0
Entertainment/wifi7.5
Meal/catering6.5

Xi'an - XIY

8.2/10
Efficiency8.0
Access8.0
Services7.0
Cleanliness10.0

Beijing - PEK

8.8/10
Efficiency10.0
Access7.0
Services8.0
Cleanliness10.0

Conclusion

A domestic Air China flight slightly below standard, apart from the legroom which was way above average, and the absence of a neighbor. But the meal was below expectations, in quantity and quality.
The erroneous counter indication at XIY is a bad point, but it did not create much hassle.
The arrival at Terminal 3D is a disadvantage, because that implies a bus transfer which provides next to zero plane spotting opportunities (the usual compensation for a bus transfer). I also suspect that the luggage delivery delay, also below local standards, was due to this terminal being slightly further away.

Information on the route Xi'an (XIY) Beijing (PEK)

Les contributeurs de Flight-Report ont posté 6 avis concernant 3 compagnies sur la ligne Xi'an (XIY) → Beijing (PEK).


Useful

La compagnie qui obtient la meilleure moyenne est Shandong Airlines avec 8.0/10.

La durée moyenne des vols est de 1 heures et 53 minutes.

  More information

4 Comments

If you liked this review or if you have any questions, don’t hesitate to post a comment below !
  • Comment 156083 by
    dw55 45 Comments
    Thank you for taking us to Huashan! The planks trail looks really scary. The breathtaking view is well worth the climb!
    Fire on everyone - those English signs never cease to amuse me.
    The low altitude makes it a really picturesque flight!
    The sandwich looks pretty bad, but at least they give it out for free. US airlines charge like $10 for the same thing.
    Chang An Airlines' livery looks the same as Hainan and HX. I guess they're all the same company?
    Weather looks really good, and it's so rare to see a blue sky in Beijing!
    I've never been to Terminal 3D, and I don't quite understand the logistics. There's no APM between 3D and baggage claim?
    • Comment 333476 by
      marathon GOLD AUTHOR 10093 Comments
      Huashan is really a must see, and because it is far enough from any significant urban or industrial center, there is no pollution to obscure the view if the weather is otherwise fine. On the other hand, I would advise against going there in the winter if there are snow/ice conditions - some blogs describe hair-raising situations. Heavy rains would also ruin most of the interest of getting there.
      I have an extensive photographic collection of Chinglish signs which survived the 2008 pre-Olympic “clean up” campaign.
      I would not buy this kind of sandwich; it is an offense to Chinese food quality and diversity.
      Chang An Airlines, Hainan Airlines and HX (plus others) are indeed part of the HNA group, which curiously preserves the identity of a number of airlines that it absorbed over the years.
      Terminal 3D gathered dust for years after T3 opened in 2007; using it was a first for me in 2015. There is an APM station there, and according to PEK’s website, passengers departing and arriving from T3D should use it, but I landed twice at T3D and each time had a bus transfer (this is not a statistically significant sample).
      Thanks for your comment !
  • Comment 157217 by
    NGO85 SILVER 1942 Comments
    Thanks for translating this FR for us Marathon!

    Is it just me, or is it weird that Chinese BPs don't have the departure time of the flight listed, only the boarding time? Is this to help simplify things so people don't get confused about when they need to be at the gate? If so, this should be adopted in the US^^

    wears pants with a slit behind, so that it is not necessary to remove it for defecating...
    - Me too!

    If you look closely in your safety pictographs, there are some gender biases. It's always a female employee with male passengers and a male employee with female passengers.

    Great spotting as always, helped by the lack of haze at the airport (also, you arrival shots were very clear in PEK, I didn't expect that in the summer months when it should be more smoggy).

    I see this plane has the new upholstery in J, since it switched form grey to blue. You have a very royal seat pitch of one The China Daily. I started using barf bags as a form of measurement since those also seem to be a standard size.

    The sandwich is a Chinese kind that I had already tasted and which I found quite stodgy.
    - No chicken with rice?

    I'm surprised you got a gate at PEK, what a luxury^^

    Fantastic bonus as always Marathon! Beautiful photos, but I wouldn't trust my life with some wood planks on the edge of cliff^^
    • Comment 334485 by
      marathon GOLD AUTHOR 10093 Comments
      “Is it just me, or is it weird that Chinese BPs don't have the departure time of the flight listed, only the boarding time? Is this to help simplify things so people don't get confused about when they need to be at the gate? If so, this should be adopted in the US^^”

      I made a random check in my thick collection of Chinese BPs (including some prized ones in Chinese only) and yes, they all have the boarding time only, never the ETD. I had never noticed that.

      “If you look closely in your safety pictographs, there are some gender biases. It's always a female employee with male passengers and a male employee with female passengers.”

      Maybe a statement that China rejects the gender separation enforced by some Islamic states.

      “Great spotting as always, helped by the lack of haze at the airport (also, you arrival shots were very clear in PEK, I didn't expect that in the summer months when it should be more smoggy).”

      It was a Sunday in June, which was probably less smoggy because of less industrial activity in the week-end, no domestic heating with poor quality coal, and less humidity than in July-August. Maybe a change in wind direction had swept the pollution away, too. I’ve had beautiful week-ends following miserable weeks in my office in Beijing.

      “I see this plane has the new upholstery in J, since it switched form grey to blue. You have a very royal seat pitch of one The China Daily. I started using barf bags as a form of measurement since those also seem to be a standard size.”

      Does the size of a barf bag remain standard after use ? ;)

      The sandwich is a Chinese kind that I had already tasted and which I found quite stodgy.
      - No chicken with rice?”
      No, and this was a clear disappointment :(


      “Fantastic bonus as always Marathon! Beautiful photos, but I wouldn't trust my life with some wood planks on the edge of cliff^^”
      I wonder why my wife refused to “hike” on this trail with me ?

      Thanks for your comments – I’m glad that you liked the bonus too !

Login to post a comment.