Review of American Airlines flight Chicago Manchester in Premium Eco

Airline American Airlines
Flight AA54
Class Premium Eco
Seat 12F
Aircraft Boeing 757-200
Flight time 07:30
Take-off 19 Dec 16, 19:05
Arrival at 20 Dec 16, 08:35
AA   #69 out of 96 Airlines A minimum of 10 flight-reports within the past two years is required to appear in the rankings. 591 reviews
jish.b
By 2804
Published on 22nd October 2017
Onwards and forwards after a terrible December 18th, lets keep going with a flight that should've been on an Etihad Airways B777-300ER, but instead was on an American Airlines B757-200. I wasn't complaining, I was just glad to have been with a solution to head home!
photo dsc_1370

MY LONGEST NARROWBODY FLIGHT!


This was going to be my longest flight on a narrow body aircraft. With this trip, the longest narrow body flight record would've been a new one anyway, seeing as Etihad operate an Airbus A320 between Abu Dhabi and Kolkata. With the rebooked itinerary, Chicago to Manchester would be my longest flight on a narrow body. 3820 miles, 6147 kilometers. Across the Atlantic! I was glad this would be a Boeing airplane, and not an Airbus one :P The B757 has been put to fantastic use by the American airlines. There are so many transatlantic routes that are operated by both variants of the B757. As far as I have heard, both Delta and United have top-notch seat back IFE on their TATL B757s, while American Airlines is a bit on the old side - no IFE whatsoever. I was quietly excited to be on a B757 again, seeing as my first ever flight since I was born was on a Royal Nepal B757.

THE FORCE AWAKENS - THE DAY OF THE FLGIHT!


Keeping up with the Star Wars titles, this is the last one, (promise :P ). December 18th 2016. It was a terrible day for my girlfriend and I. A long day with everything going wrong - flight delays, missing flights, unhelpful staff… It all turned around about 15 hours after when we got a revised itinerary all the way to Kolkata from Chicago (seeing as we made it from Fargo in the most unfortunate of circumstances). Being Christmas time, most flights out were full. I truly appreciated the fact that my girlfriend (who was traveling internationally for the first time) and I were on the same set of flights! With those in mind, we slept off peacefully in to the night.

The next morning, we woke up about 12 hours before departure for our flight to Manchester, UK. In the little time I got here and there - I figured out that this flight would actually be in Economy Plus - more legroom the better, I guess! :D N196AA, a 15.2 year old Boeing 757-200W would take us across the Atlantic. She was just about to take off from Manchester for its flight back to Chicago as AA53. AA54/AA53 are continuation of a flight from Orlando to Chicago on an A321.

THE BAGGAGE DILEMMA?!


Breakfast at the hotel, albeit basic, was quite filling. Since we were entitled to a free breakfast anyway, we had an extra voucher to use during the long day of killing time. We had to depart at around 0930/10am - a concern that kept me from being high spirited after the rebooking was the luggage. I mentioned in the previous part that Etihad would have our baggage, and that we should be at the Etihad check in at around 11am to make sure we get them back.

Shuttle ride was a bit long - but we made it at Terminal 5 in the nick of time! Trust me, at this point I was really starting to dislike T5, but thankfully the Etihad staff were still around. The lovely young lady from Texas did her thing and helped us, while telling us how much she disliked the cold - at least it wasn’t North Dakota! She informed us to stick around for a while, it would take some time before they found our suitcases. No, we were not the reason Etihad flight EY150 was delayed by over three hours the previous day - it was unfortunately compounded by American Airlines and American Eagle's operations that blew things out of proportion.

Some spotting pictures:
photo dsc_1260photo dsc_1262

A6-ETJ had flown in to Abu Dhabi as EY151.
photo dsc_1264photo dsc_1265

With us being hopeful about receiving our luggage, we headed out towards the city - I quite liked the Chicago blue line metro and I wanted to take my girlfriend on it. However, a worrying thing was the fact that telephone signal was dropping. This would pose a threat if Etihad tried to call us back, they wouldn’t be able to. I think we went up to Belmont and took the train back. This worked out perfectly - onboard the inter terminal tram from T2 to T5, we got a call from Etihad! The staff member would be waiting with our luggage at the check in area.

Another nice young lady helped us out - another persons’ suitcase was there too, but he was no where to be seen. She insisted to take the baggage cart all the way for convenience - only to realize these weren’t allowed on the inter terminal tram! :D

CHECK IN, ROUND 2!


1305 hours. About six hours till we departed - out of the USA! We headed to T3 and joined a long international check in line - thankfully this was fast moving! We spent about thirty minutes in line since our baggage tags would not print. Not too bad. Once at the check in counter where we had to drop off our luggage - everything was in order. However we did have to wait for a good twenty odd minutes here.
photo img_5009photo img_5012

WHAT, NO FRAGILE TAGS?!


photo img_5014
When I requested for a fragile tag, the agent told me that they did not do it anymore. I decided to turn cheeky. ’Oh, so that’s why so many bags are mishandled’ I said. ‘Uhh no sir we take utmost care of the luggage while loading and it’s at the passengers risk’ said the check in lady, getting a bit defensive. ‘Right. Okay. Thanks.’, I said as I walked away. At least I was now confident we’d be on our way! It was 1415 hours.

WE'RE (ALMOST) ON OUR WAY!


With 5 hours to kill, we went downstairs to use up the second of the three free vouchers - the breakfast voucher was of least value, so what better than using it to get some Starbucks?! A final pumpkin spice latte for the year.
photo img_5016photo img_5018photo img_5020

Once this was done, I saw D-ABYJ, the Lufthansa B747-8 from Frankfurt preparing for its taxi from T5 to T1. I insisted we board the tram so that I could perhaps get a decent shot of it. This did not work out - D-ABYJ was already at T1, so we decided to kill time by heading all the way to the parking. A nice looking Austrian B767-300ER was parked:
photo dsc_1269

SECURITY - ULTIMATE LEVEL OF CUTENESS?!


After all the goofing around - we finally decided to head for security. 1516 hours. Under 4 hours to departure. So close! This was very quick - a cute member of the K9 family ensured we were all cleared, and so there was no need for regular security. Just the bag through the X-ray machine, no need for removing laptops, no need for removing shoes! This was great. 1520 hours, and we were airside.
photo img_5035photo img_5037

Airside:
photo img_5039

Prior to the Kevin Mcallister part (where Kevin and his family spilt up before the flight to New York and Miami respectively in Home Alone 2), there were lovely Christmas decorations, and a choir who really set up a cute christmas spirit! They sang some very populars hymns and songs - every one waited to witness and experience this, even a couple of pilots! At concourse K, I did my spotting stuff as my girlfriend dealt with…there’s only so much an avgeek can not do :P
photo img_5041photo img_5047

That’s when I decided to head to concourse L - this had a very nice view of activity going past the international Terminal 5. 1545 hours - almost time for KLM’s B747-400M departure to Amsterdam! :D I found a spot right by the glass and I had a great spotting session. Prior to that, some pictures along the way:
Gonna miss the Mad Dogs and the old livery, that's for sure…
photo img_5053photo img_5055

N196AA was docked at gate M1, and was pushed back at 1610. This later taxied towards gate K10. Let the pictures do the talking:
photo dsc_1271

The biggies - KLM, Emirates, Delta (DL has since exited the international market at ORD, handing over the Paris CDG flight to Air France permanently.)
photo dsc_1276

And this American Airlines B787 was significant. I pointed out to my girlfriend the unique nose section and engine cowlings that set the Dream)liner away from the others. We would have 2 Dream)liner flights after we get to Manchester.
photo dsc_1280

American A321, ex-US Airways is my guess
photo dsc_1281

'If its not pointy, its not scary.'
photo dsc_1287

Gotta say, after the day prior to this one, I absolutely disliked the ERJ-145….
photo dsc_1288

B737-800
photo dsc_1289

A fantastic airplane!
photo dsc_1294

Not enough B787 pictures, that's for sure…
photo dsc_1295

Another oldie
photo dsc_1296

ERJ-175
photo dsc_1297

The three liveries! Which one is your favorite?!
photo dsc_1300

THAT'S TOO MUCH OF AMERICAN!!


It is, it is. I too was surprised to see so many American Airlines planes. After all, this is one of their hubs. Some other stuff too. Starting off with the home airline - United!
photo dsc_1303

Spirit
photo img_5061

Beastly Korean Air Cargo B777-200F
photo img_5068

Frontier
photo dsc_1308

Some more American :P
MD-83, and a B767-300ER
photo dsc_1305photo dsc_1306

Swiss A330-300 to/from Zurich
photo dsc_1310

Aer Lingus A330 from Dublin
photo dsc_1317

Some pictures of N196AA heading out of gate M1 after arrival from Manchester…


The Aer Lingus A330-300 chased it down
photo dsc_1327

The moment had arrived - KLM B747-400M PH-BFC operating a delayed KL612 departure to Amsterdam Schiphol. Oh, how I miss the simpler times….
photo dsc_1335

Not too long after - another majestic moment! Lufthansa B747-8 D-ABYM operating LH431 to Frankfurt. Oh, how I miss the simpler times…..
photo dsc_1339

BACK TO THE FLIGHT!


After a supper courtesy of American Eagle, we headed back to gate K10.
photo img_5123photo img_5126

Was loving the celebration mode at ORD - amazing, I was absolutely hating ORD not more than 24 hours ago….
photo img_5128

Headed towards Gate K10 - no aircraft was present. So where was N196AA?! Fearing another delay, I tried to stay calm. There was the Iberia A330-300 at the departure gate K13, all set to depart. It was quite hilarious to see ground staff close the forward cargo door, only to reopen it because their clipboard was left inside the cargo hold :D
photo dsc_1354photo dsc_1356photo dsc_1359

Some others in the vicinity:
AA B77E
photo dsc_1342photo dsc_1346

MD-83
photo dsc_1349

HELLO, PENCIL JET!


While the pretty Iberia bird departed (some lovely sounds being made by the GE CF6 engines), N196AA showed up. I have no idea where she was parked, but hey she docked at the gate, just 55 minutes before our departure time. Heading back to Gate K13 while the pre-boarding announcement was on, it was unsurprising to see that the gate had no place to sit. We sat on the floor.


Revised!!
photo img_5137

Our birdie - looking quite sleek
photo dsc_1370

BOARDING, BOARDING, BOARDING!


The golden words sprouted: ‘we would like to begin boarding for American Airlines flight fifty four to Manchester’. This felt like a moral victory for us, after having been delayed so much. Business class first, followed by the rear end of Economy, and then it was our turn. 1854 hours, we were in line for boarding.

Putting behind the rather mediocre flight I had with American Airlines in May, and the rather atrocious state of affairs the previous day, I was quietly excited for my longest flight on a Narrow Body! It was time to make the most of the lost time.

Gate:
photo img_5138

Long line in the jet bridge -
photo img_5140

Almost there!
photo img_5143photo img_5144photo img_5145

I was onboard at 1858 hours, seven minutes prior to departure time. No, there wasn’t a crew member at the doorway. I took my seat 12F, which had a fantastic view of the starboard Rolls Royce RB211-535E4B engine.
photo img_5148

Wasn’t too alarmed by the lack of IFE - I was fortunate to have someone sit beside me…her second flight in the middle seat. Besides, I was glad I had so much legroom! Business Class however, had PTV screens. The overhead TV screens were showing some ads of American Airlines. The crew, when they showed up, had a great Christmas spirit going on. They were cheerful, chirpy and helpful.
photo dsc_1376photo img_5151photo img_5153

Legroom!!!!
photo img_5155

DEPARTURE
Doors armed at 1922 hours, and pushback commenced at 1925 hours, twenty minutes after scheduled departure time. An American B777 was pushed back, so I guess we just blocked its way for a while. Firing up the two engines sounded like things just out of heaven - a low rumbling hum!
photo img_5156photo img_5161

So close, so close, so close…
photo dsc_1383

Taxiing to runway 28R was just under 20 minutes. Thundered down the runway at 1946 hours - to the lovely sounds of two Rolls Royce RB211 engines whirring their way in the cold air, decimating the peace that was around in Chicago O'Hare, as we took off in to the starry skies over a well lit Chicago. I absolutely loved the sounds of the engines. It was so easy to fall asleep to! Announcements made were through the automated robot voice… no surprise there, I guess.

photo img_5168photo dsc_1386

INFLIGHT


A 'perk' of Economy Comfort on these B757s are the power ports under the seat - two ports for three seats. However, these were taped off and not available for use, unfortunately. :(
photo img_5265
However, this was nothing to be unhappy about. I was very excited to be onboard this flight as I was finally heading home! Once these announcements were complete, the movies began, starting out with the new Pete's Dragon.

The captain came over the PA and gave us some quick details of our flight - we were cruising at a rather low 27000 feet. We were expecting to land in Manchester at 0820 hours, an overcast day with a temperature of 6C was awaiting us.

I received my dinner at 2017 hours CST - an ode to the new year? :P The two crew members serving us were very cheerful, and played along with the Christmas spirit - they had very cute rice lights lighting up in different colors! A nice added touch :)
photo img_5177

I opted for the roast chicken meal. Unsurprisingly, this was one of the two choices for supper, the other being pasta.
The meal came with a relatively fresh salad (carrots, cabbage and cucumber), a small bottle of water, a pre-packaged brownie, cheese and crackers.
photo img_5184photo img_5185photo img_5190

The main course itself consisted of rosemary roasted chicken, mashed potatoes and boiled vegetables. Pretty standard fare on a TATL route, but this sure did taste pretty decent!
photo img_5179

With this flight, I had the chance of trying out the three major American carriers on a Transatlantic flight. Suffice to say, this supper slotted in to second place, behind Delta’s lunch on CDG-ORD and way ahead of UA’s lunch on MUC-ORD. Well done, AA! Oh, there was a can of Heineken beer involved, too. No IDs required :)
photo img_5189photo img_5194

Once trays were cleared away, there was another beverage service. I had some apple juice.
photo img_5195

The sounds of the RR RB211 engines whirring away made for a very chill background as my girlfriend and I watched a couple of documentaries about India’s Frontier Railways on Netflix - the Maitree Express from Kolkata (India) to Dhaka (Bangladesh), and the Samjautha Express from Delhi (India) to Lahore (Pakistan). Two very entertaining hours and a lot of railway stories, this flight was passing by pretty quickly. I was loving it.
photo img_5197

The flight passed through without too much of a hitch - very smooth and very calming (the sound of the RR RB211 engines, of course). We passed over a snowy Nova Scotia and over the Atlantic.
photo dsc_1388photo dsc_1391photo img_5204

IFE controls -
photo img_5214

Lights were dimmed for the most of the flight, but very few passengers were awake and doing their own thing. Seat pockets had both an English and Spanish magazine featuring Casey Affleck. While flipping through the magazines I noticed that American Airlines has a grand total of 931 planes in their mainline fleet (51 of which are B757-200s, and the largest A320 family fleet), and 628 in the 'American Eagles' fleet. A total of 1559 planes in the fleet! The second movie that was being played was ‘Focus' featuring Will Smith and Margot Robbie.


Pillow and blanket for the long haul..
photo img_5228

0708 hours GMT - I received my breakfast box. "Good morning!" said the lovely flight attendant. "Would you like to join us for breakfast?" I gladly accepted the box. The continental breakfast contained an orange & cranberry muffin top, dried fruits (cranberries, apples and blueberries), cereal and yogurt. Are you seeing this, Lufthansa? :)
photo img_5252photo img_5254photo img_5255

People slowly getting active…
photo dsc_1395

As the boxes were being cleared away, I made a quick restroom visit - this was kept very clean, even at the closing stages of the flight.
photo img_5257photo img_5259

DESCENT


Land ho! We saw Ireland wake up to the sunrise, as some lights were still on. The joys of a sunrise flight! A beautiful orange line divided the horizon of the blue skies and dark land. The Captain came back over the PA at 0738 hours. We’d arrive in just over half an hour, while the weather held station.

i always enjoy the sunrise from a plane, especially when its just your 'typical' transatlantic flight. Check out these pictures -


We cut through some reasonably thin clouds, and circled for a bit over Manchester. As we dipped below the clouds, the first thing I noticed was the fact that people were driving on the right side of the road. And by the right side, I mean Left Hand Drive :P
photo dsc_1415photo dsc_1418photo dsc_1422

ARRIVAL


The outskirts of Manchester were awake as we flew over the M60 and M67 highways. My first time in to the United Kingdom, even if it was just a transit!
photo img_5268photo img_5269

We lined up with Runway 23R and touched down smoothly at 0810 hours, a whole twenty five minutes before time. Hey, I didn’t mind arriving this early, especially after the delays of the previous flight! :P

Other than a plethora of Ryanair planes, there was an Emirates B777-300ER and a Lufthansa Airbus A380-800, the latter which was a surprise. I later found out that this was because of……. http://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manchester-news/blunder-lufthansa-planes-emergency-slide-12351447
photo img_5272photo img_5273

Wonder what this is…?
photo dsc_1424

After some more robotic announcements, the crew member informed us of the time and thanked us for choosing to fly American….urhm, yeah about that :P
We taxied to Gate 54 in terminal 3. I was a little nervous about how I’d be able to go from T3 to T1 without passing through immigration. Engines cut out, the ground staff got to work and unloaded all bags - no threat of a strike on the day! Things were going swell.
photo dsc_1426photo img_5276

Disembarking -
photo img_5278photo img_5280

We disembarked and headed through T3. N196AA would later fly to JFK as AA211.
photo dsc_1431

FlyBE regional birdies
photo dsc_1428

I wonder how long this sign'll be around for…
photo img_5285

My concerns of the transit were soon quashed as I saw signs for transit passengers divided by airlines. With the Qatar Airways flight coming up next, I was looking forward to just heading through transit security and freshening up.
photo img_5287

Up next…
photo dsc_1458
See more

Verdict

American Airlines

8.0/10
Cabin7.5
Cabin crew8.5
Entertainment/wifi7.5
Meal/catering8.5

Chicago - ORD

7.1/10
Efficiency6.5
Access7.0
Services8.0
Cleanliness7.0

Manchester - MAN

8.1/10
Efficiency7.5
Access8.5
Services7.5
Cleanliness9.0

Conclusion

I quite liked what I experienced onboard American Airlines’ long haul product. Sure, there was no IFE. Sure, I was in Economy Comfort which helped legroom. However, the food was nice, the flight was on time, and the crew nice and spirited. For those of you who did point out I was being a little harsh on the American airlines following my United debacle from MUC to ORD, take note. :) Bring it on, Qatar Airways!

Related

1 Comments

If you liked this review or if you have any questions, don’t hesitate to post a comment below !
  • Comment 416970 by
    757Fan 632 Comments
    Great report. After your bad day the day before, I'm glad you had an easy flight across the ocean with AA. It looks like you had a pretty good flight with them - I didn't realize that AA operated a ORD-MAN flight. Great that you also got on a 757 - it's my favorite jet!

    Thanks for sharing.

Login to post a comment.