Review of KLM Cityhopper flight Amsterdam Lyon in Economy

Airline KLM Cityhopper
Flight KL1419
Class Economy
Seat 14A
Aircraft Embraer E-190
Flight time 02:20
Take-off 15 Feb 22, 23:05
Arrival at 16 Feb 22, 01:25
WA   #49 out of 94 Airlines A minimum of 10 flight-reports within the past two years is required to appear in the rankings. 521 reviews
ChrisB
By GOLD 347
Published on 24th May 2023

a single flight but two planes and two cabins!


Hello all and welcome on this last episode.


Flying blue miles claimed: 224
XP earned: 8 (AF/KL was offering 50% more XP in 2022)


The whole return journey with Turkish Airlines was just €20 more expensive, but half of the trip was to be operated in a Boeing 737Max9 , and no offence but I am not sure how much we could trust the Boeing validation team.. 



photo 20220221_161821

KLM City hopper has about 30 units of the E190 type of 100 seats, together with further 17 E175, and the new E2-195, I guess Hop would be jealous!


photo cd9c1323-bb82-45c1-8c033d2ffbe0964c

at the klm - lounge 52


The other main interest of this flight was to enjoy about 1h30 at the non schengen lounge, which, as I was about to discover, is far better than the KLM European lounge.

The entrance decorated with the famous KLM Gin house. 


photo 20220215_193827photo 20220215_193840

In theory we shouldn't be in the lounge as our next flight is within the Schengen area but the lady at the counter let us in and just warns us that we need to leave enough time to go through passport control. 


photo 20220215_194133

This lounge is really vast compares to the other one, and has a lot more dedicated spaces.


photo 20220215_194149

Really like these paintings next to the bar, a really good idea.


photo 20220215_194453

Even if we are late in the afternoon, the FIDS displays a lot of evening flights.


photo 20220215_194532

A really nice feature of this lounge are the resting room, shame they aren't free though.


photo 20220215_194606

Waiters at the bar are really friendly and I will indulge myself with a well deserved GinT!


photo 20220215_195228-58992

A lot of people at the food buffets.


photo 20220215_195409-99907

KLM lounges aren't known for the quality of the food they provide, it is not bad just really average.


photo 20220215_195509

Let's continue the visit of the lounge.
A lot more sofas around here. 


photo 20220215_200630

And the famous KLM mountain - an area of the lounge that is really well decorated. Have you seen the disco ball?


photo 20220215_200655photo 20220215_200718

The movie theatre..


photo 20220215_200746

The rooftop bar was unfortunately closed.


photo 20220215_200807photo 20220215_200850

The second escalator leading to the rooftop bar, with even more of these Amsterdam houses.


photo 20220215_200934

There is coworking space, but don't you worry I didn't use it :p


photo 20220215_201418

We go through passport control in the blink of an eye 

so… with a good 40 min left before boarding what else can we do??



Let's go and visit the Schengen area KLM lounge! 


photo 20220215_203554

It is already "late" and the lounge will no longer serve food passed 9pm. You'd better not fancy eating at Spanish time!


photo 20220215_204108

onboard the E190 take 1


We arrive at our gate on the B concourse where a paxbus will take us to PH-EZE


Which reminds me how much I'd love to go back to Buenos Aires again!


photo 20220215_21155

Sorry for the blurry pictures.


photo 20220215_211224

Aircraft: Embraer ERJ190STD
Tail number: PH-EZE
Engines: 2x GE CF34
Age: 12 years old
Layout: Y100


The cabin crew is super friendly.

First time I am seeing the new cabin on KLM City Hopper.


photo 20220215_211250-3564

Pros:
-It looks more modern
-Same new cabin across the entire KLM fleet

Cons:
-Seat does not recline (unlike the previous generation of seats)
-Seat is really thin, and less confortable, a different league than the previous seats
-Seat are also narrower


photo 20220215_211443-34766photo 20220215_212009photo 20220215_212115




I can't believe how much narrower the seats are, and now there is all this empty space between two seats.    


photo 20220215_215418

The seats are equipped power sockets, a real plus compares to the older cabin.


photo 20220215_212146photo 20220215_211754

The safety card, also found on the E175


photo 20220215_211639

We are taxiing under heavy showers to our runway.


photo 20220215_213017photo 20220215_213341

And take off!


photo 20220215_213724

The cabin crew start going through the cabin really quickly after the seat belt sign is turned off, to quickyl deem the cabin lights and let the passenger go to sleep. A nice gesture.

A trolley is never really sexy and it is nice that KLM at least put a picture on it.


photo 20220215_220009

Standard egg and mayo sandwich from KLM - not the best but at least is part of the flight ticket.


photo 20220215_220331

I go for a little nap and when I wake up I realise the landing lights are ON… a bit odd as we are nowhere near Lyon..?


photo 20220215_222125

Shortly after the captain makes an announcement:

"dear passengers and folks, you have probably realised by now that we have made a U-turn. We have identified a problem with the aircraft but not related to safety so don't worry but we rather go back to Amsterdam. 
KLM team has already identified a plane replacement, and they are organising as we speak the transfer"

So Ok it wasn't the best of news at this point in the evening but at least the situation was well managed.


photo screenshot_20220215-225817_flightradar24

We land back in Amsterdam on the furthest runway - Polderban.


photo 20220215_222856photo 20220215_223910

Nous nous parquons au niveau du futur Pier A, ou beaucoup de KLM Shittyhoper sont garés.


photo 20220215_223913

back to amsterdam


The minute we arrived at our parking stand the bus arrived to take us to the next plane.


photo 20220215_224204

As we disembark you can realise how thin the new seats are.


photo 20220215_224627-71103photo 20220215_224702

KLM keeps us informed.


photo 20220221_161833

the world shortest bus ride..


We all get on the paxbus that slightly moves and stops for 10 min.

Our first plane is the one on the right… and the next one the one on the left!! Surely we could have walked this distance :p


photo 20220215_224901

onboard the e190 take 2


Aircrat: Embraer ERJ190STD
Tail number: PH-EXB
Engines: 2x GE CF34
Age: 8 years old
Layout: Y100


photo 20220215_23024

And I am lucky to find these older seats, at least they recline, are thick and comfy and I could see myself dozing off very quickly.


photo 20220215_231536photo 20220215_233039

We have the view on the aircraft that let us down.


photo 20220215_231613

We are pushing back a second time.


photo 20220215_233538

Taxiing along the same route…


photo img-20220216-wa0001

And as planned I fell asleep quite quickly. 
KLM maintained the legacy carrier tradition of onboard magazine, I can't think of any other European airline that does so. 


photo 20220216_160041photo 20220216_160129

KLM and Skyteam friend global network.


photo 20220216_160234

Still blurry pictures I am sorry


photo 20220216_005612

at lyon - saint-exupéry airport


photo 20220216_005636

We arrived at terminal 2 (now closed for works) gate B91/P01.


photo 20220216_005849photo 20220216_010537

The luggages are very quickly made available, which is a really good thing at this time of the night.


photo 20220216_011149

I wrote to KLM but since the european legislation changed the delayed status for compensation from 2 to 3 hours, the airline just replied to me with a nice "bye betch. XoXo".


photo reclamation
See more

Verdict

KLM Cityhopper

7.5/10
Cabin7.5
Cabin crew9.0
Entertainment/wifi6.0
Meal/catering7.5

KLM Crown Lounge 5 - Non Schengen

8.4/10
Comfort9.0
Meal/catering7.0
Entertainment/wifi8.5
Services9.0

Amsterdam - AMS

7.4/10
Efficiency6.5
Access7.0
Services7.5
Cleanliness8.5

Lyon - LYS

7.9/10
Efficiency8.0
Access7.0
Services7.5
Cleanliness9.0

Conclusion

AMS: quite flowless experience.

International KLM lounge: very confortable, a lot of different areas and a lot of services. However food is always very average.

KLM:
The technical issue and the change of aircraft made us arrived in Lyon quite late but the problem was VERY well managed by KLM. It could have been a lot worse.
I got to try the older and newer seats and I think I prefer the confort of the old cabin over a power socket.
The KLM crew is always professional.

LYS : As effecient as always

For memory here are my criteria to try and be fair at each report
-Entertainment: None < 4.5 Magazine 6< a smartphone application 7< Wifi 8 < IFE = 10
-Cabin: visually interesting, comfortable and user friendly> 7.5. For example, "Ironing boards" are <7
-Crew: Went for the extra mile, they've outdone themselves > 7.5
- Meal: : Buy On Board <5 Free <7.5< Visually interesting, satisfying, visually good and yummy

Information on the route Amsterdam (AMS) Lyon (LYS)

Les contributeurs de Flight-Report ont posté 31 avis concernant 3 compagnies sur la ligne Amsterdam (AMS) → Lyon (LYS).


Useful

La compagnie qui obtient la meilleure moyenne est KLM avec 7.4/10.

La durée moyenne des vols est de 1 heures et 35 minutes.

  More information

5 Comments

If you liked this review or if you have any questions, don’t hesitate to post a comment below !
  • Comment 629061 by
    LeMatheuxVoyageur BRONZE 833 Comments
    Hi ChrisB and thank you for this final part of your journey ! I think KLM managed the incident really good. They have been really responsive and the replacement aircraft was almost ready for departure. They gave you some information to be awared of the events and appeased passengers in saying the failure was not engaging safety. The catering onboard is classic for Skyteam passengers but is better than on almost all european carriers in economy class. Old seats are really comfy but has no USB port. LYS is in my opinion a really good airport once again. See you ;)
    • Comment 629280 by
      ChrisB GOLD AUTHOR 3426 Comments
      Hi Yann,
      thanks for your comment!
      I was pleasantly surprised by KLM which managed the incident pretty well.
      The catering onboard is classic for Skyteam passengers but is better than on almost all european carriers in economy class.

      Exactly. not great but better than than others.
      See you :)
  • Comment 629407 by
    KévinDC TEAM SILVER 6731 Comments
    Great that you were able to use the "good" lounge during transit. If you have time, it's smart to stay on the non-Schengen side for the better lounge. It's certainly a lot nice than the KLM Frown Lounge I remember from years ago when I still flew SkyTeam.

    It's too bad that the new seats aren't very comfortable, and you're right that it's weird that the seats are so narrow with that huge gap between seats. It's really a shame because Embraers have a wide cabin for 2-2 and can support 18.5" wide seats, which are normally much wider than 737s (typically 17" wide) and A320 family (typically 17.5-18" wide). Sounds like KLM didn't make full use of that space! The power is clearly an improvement over the older seats.

    I guess after the whole ordeal of having to return to AMS, it was good to get an older cabin for more comfort. I'd be super tired by that point and want to sleep.

    Thanks for sharing!
    • Comment 629694 by
      ChrisB GOLD AUTHOR 3426 Comments
      Hi Kevin,
      thanks for stopping by! Yes I was lucky to be able to visit the right lounge! The other one doesn't so much feel like a "crown" lol
      KLM Frown Lounge

      aAHAHAHAHH I love the name.
      The seats are a bit funny not in a good way...
      Sounds like KLM didn't make full use of that space!

      Maybe motivated by a weight criteria again..
      I'd be super tired by that point and want to sleep.

      I was and I was really "releaved" to see the old seats.
  • Comment 629692 by
    ChrisB GOLD AUTHOR 3426 Comments
    Hi Kevin,
    thanks for stopping by! Yes I was lucky to be able to visit the right lounge! The other one doesn't so much feel like a "crown" lol
    KLM Frown Lounge

    aAHAHAHAHH I love the name.
    The seats are a bit funny not in a good way...
    Sounds like KLM didn't make full use of that space!

    Maybe motivated by a weight criteria again..
    I'd be super tired by that point and want to sleep.

    I was and I was really "releaved" to see the old seats.

Login to post a comment.