Review of American Airlines flight from New York to London in Business

AAL

AA - American Airlines

Flight taken on 22 December 2023
AA142
10:09 05h 51m 21:46
Class Business
Seat 9L
YGeorgeW
1,523 · 66 · 5 · 7

return to asia


When China reopened this year, I knew I'd want to visit my extended family for the first time since before the pandemic, but timing was tricky with work, so it ended up being this was the earliest I could take the trip (and sufficient time off to make a trek to Asia worthwhile).  Compared 5 years ago, I'm less enthused about these kind of crazy routings try to different premium products, but this time I planned the trip around 1) a Cathay F award and originally a cheap fare out of Bangkok (that got delayed and forced me to re-route to get home in time).

The first part of this trip was done on a cash fare round-trip between JFK and LHR; combined with an Amex Offer for $300 off and the British Airways AARP discount.  After all the savings were factored in, it was more than a comfortable enough price for me.

This would be the first time I've flown on a OW business class and first time on an international premium cabin for a US airline other than United.


Flight routing

  • 1
    AA142 - Business - New York → London - Boeing 777-200
  • 2
    CX254 - First - London → Hong Kong - Boeing 777-300ER
  • 3
    CX356 - Business - Hong Kong → Nanjing - Airbus A321neo
  • 4
    CZ3816 - Business - Hefei → Guangzhou - Boeing 737-700
  • 5
    CZ3081 - Business - Guangzhou → Bangkok - Airbus A350-900
  • 6
    TG930 - Business - Bangkok → Paris - Boeing 777-300ER
  • 7
    LH1027 - Business - Paris → Frankfurt - Airbus A320
  • 8
    LH418 - Business - Frankfurt → Washington - Boeing 747-400

photo trip-to-asia

jfk terminal 8 premium check-in


I took an Uber to JFK fairly early, fearing a pre-Christmas rush of passengers on the roads that Friday, but it turned out to be a relatively quiet morning.  The premium check-in for American Airlines and British Airways can be found at the right end of Terminal 8.


photo 20231222_074912-30816

It's simply a more quiet area to check-in that leads directly to the TSA Pre line (AA doesn't allow CLEAR at terminals it controls).


photo 20231222_074943

It was a pretty quick trip through TSA Pre–not many travelers that morning.


photo 20231222_080342

Walking into the terminal after security, you'll come across this cool American Airlines plane model.  The Greenwich lounge can be found to the left while the other two, fancier lounges are to the right.


photo 20231222_080422

Having absolutely no status in Oneworld, I turned left to the Greenwich Lounge, which can be found immediately up a set of elevators.


photo 20231222_080518

greenwich lounge jfk


Check-In was quiet with one gentleman who was very confused about what happened to the Admiral's Club that used to be here.


photo 20231222_080618-99984

I was quickly checked in and welcomed to the lounge down a narrow corridor.  There are some seating here if the lounge is absolutely packed for whatever reason, but otherwise there is no reason to sit here.


photo 20231222_080722

The Greenwich Lounge is primarily one big room with various types of seating, a buffet area, and a self-serve beverage area.


photo 20231222_080740

There's also a quiet room immediately to your left after you enter.  I didn't even realize this room was here until I was on my way out of the lounge, so I did not stop in for a picture.


photo 20231222_090834

There are a lot of different types of seats, ranging from standard lounge chairs, counter seating, high-back chairs, and tarmac view lounge seats.  The last type were the most naturally and all occupied when I looked around.  Overall, the lounge had more people at 8:30am on a Friday morning than I expected, but there were plenty of open seats.





The Tasting Room and the Coffee Bar were closed until 10:30am according to a sign.


photo 20231222_080757

I settled down in one of the working booths.  While these were open, it was a pretty efficient use of space and comfortable to hammer out emails pre-flight.  One nice thing about the lounge throughout was the prevalence of outlets everywhere.


photo 20231222_080920

The WiFi speed of the lounge was rather lackluster, but enough to get basic emailing done.


photo screenshot-2023-12-22-082737

The buffet area had a salad bar, some bread and bagels, and your standard hot breakfast: scrambled eggs, bacon, potatoes.  This is also where you can find the liquors and various other beverages like the coffee machines, beer, juices, etc.  There is also another coffee setup elsewhere in the lounge.





In the center of the lounge was a self-serve wine bar.  The Greenwich Lounge serves Piper Heidseick, which is decent enough for a business-class lounge.





I just grabbed a cappuccino and a small plate of a little bit of everything.


photo 20231222_081802

Before leaving the lounge, I checked out the restroom, which was clean and spacious.


photo 20231222_085427

The Greenwich Lounge has D.S. & Durga amenities.


photo 20231222_085511

I left the lounge about 15 minutes before boarding to make my way to Gate 4.


aa142


My flight to London was on N772AN, a 24 years old 777-200ER.


photo 20231222_091325

Boarding began on-time at 9:21, nearly 50 minutes before takeoff.  There weren't any Concierge Key members as far as I could tell, and then all the OW Emerald and business class passengers boarded next.

AA's 772s' newer business class is separated into two cabins.  The forward cabin has 5 rows of business (plus a single seat in its own row) and the back cabin has 4 rows arranged in 1-2-1.


photo 20231222_092251

Today I was on one of the AA 772s with the popular Super Diamond variant of the reverse herringbone seats.  I sat in 9L, the right-side window seat in the second to last row.


photo 20231222_092359

There's a good bit of storage for travel documents, chargers, and other similar small items.  The seat control was set in a touchscreen to the right of the seat and easy to use.  There's a standard reading light and two air nozzles.  I'll let most of the pictures for the seat speak for itself.

At boarding, a menu, headphones, the amenity kit, and a bottle of water were already waiting in the seat.





The IFE was crisp and responsive.  Nothing more to report.  Sorry for the angle, but I was trying to avoid as much of the reflection as possible.


photo 20231222_092835

You can see that there is a good amount of space in the footwell, though it narrows quite a bit towards the end.


photo 20231222_092558

I didn't notice this until a few minutes after I had sat down, but my seat was missing the bedding for some reason.  This was a day-time flight so I didn't even bother raising the issue: I didn't want to deal with the bedding taking up extra space in my seat when I was unlikely to bother using it.


photo 20231222_092543

The amenity is pretty basic, seen below.  I grabbed what I needed and did not keep the kit.


photo 20231222_093152

This is the one area where you can compare American Airlines business class with . . . Singapore First Class?  They both have Bang & Olufsen headphones, which are very nice.


photo 20231222_095815

Sandy was the flight attendant working the back starboard aisle.  She was wearing a Santa hat and I could tell immediately she was going to be great.  Sandy addressed me by name and offered a choice of predeparture beverages.  I went with champagne and was pleasantly surprised upon tasting it that it was actually champagne–I was under the impression that American had downgraded at least the predeparture sparkling option to prosecco.


photo 20231222_094141

The nifty part about sitting in row 9 was that it offered an unparalleled view of the beautiful engine and wing.

Boarding completed at 10:05am ET and we pushed back 4 minutes later, two minutes before the scheduled departure time.


photo 20231222_100117

We taxied for quite a while before taking off at 10:33am ET.

Here, you can see Long Island and the Atlantic Ocean beyond it.


photo 20231222_103545

Before takeoff, Sandy was busy taking orders from every passenger and stopped by my seat to confirm that I preordered the braised short rib.  I figured that I'd do a comparison with the UA short rib since I'm so used to that one.  Here's the pre-order menu.


photo screenshot-2023-12-18-190731photo screenshot-2023-12-18-190743

Below is the menu.  If you compare it with the pre-order menu, it looks like the Harvest Vegetable and Grain Bowl and the Golden Roasted Chicken are not available as order-onboard options.  Recently, AA for whatever reason stopped printing the wine list and instead tells passengers to ask the FAs.  It seems quite unrealistic to expect FAs to memorize the wine list (specifically the actual producers, vintages, etc . . .).  


photo 20231222_092700photo 20231222_092705

Service began began 20 minutes after takeoff with a hot towel.


photo 20231222_105724

Sandy and Jerry came with the beverage cart about 15 minutes later.  I had champagne, which I noticed was Duval Leroy Brut–a reasonable business class champagne.  Warm nuts and a glass of water were served alongside the champagne.

I didn't ask for the full wine menu as I didn't intend to drink much beyond this glass of champagne on this flight.  I overheard Jerry informing the passenger in front of me that for white wine they had chardonnay and sauvignon blanc available. 


photo 20231222_111213

Appetizers came next: salad and grilled Cajun shrimp.  It was passable, though I have no idea what was Cajun about the shrimp preparation.


photo 20231222_112412

Sandy stopped by with the bread basket shortly after appetizers were served and I selected pretzel bread, as is my preference when it's available.


photo 20231222_112715

The braised short rib was . . . okay.  It was tougher than what I'm used on UA and the sides were a bit hard.


photo 20231222_113830

I had the ice cream sundae afterwards.  No cart on AA, but Sandy asked what toppings I would like to go along with it.  I opted for a simple mix of nuts, hot fudge, and caramel.  The fudge wasn't hot and the ice cream was solidly frozen when I got it, but after it melted a bit it was pretty good.  I'm rarely ever going to complain about an ice cream sundae.


photo 20231222_115902

In all, service took about 90 minutes and my tray table was cleaned up sometime around 110 minutes to two hours after takeoff.

I checked out the lavatory afterwards.  I approve of the larger basin, but AA could really use a bit more amenities in the lavatory, even if it's just moisturizing lotion.





When returning to my seat, I realized that the aisle-side armrest not only goes up, but also doubled as a small storage for additional small items.


photo 20231222_115638-19223

I watched movies and dozed in and out of sleep for most of the flight.  With about 80 minutes left inflight, Sandy asked if I wanted breakfast.  I always get a kick when airlines call it breakfast even though we were past 8pm GMT.  In any case, I tried the toasted croque monsieur sandwich.  It was decent, albeit too heavy given that I had just eaten a few hours before.


photo 20231222_151306

AA came around with its UNICEF donation bags with around 35 minutes left inflight and we began our descent into LHR 10 minutes later.  Sandy came by to thank all of the passengers in her aisle began landing–a nice gesture.


photo 20231222_162737

We landed at 9:35pm and arrived at our gate 11 minutes after a short wait–24 minutes early. 

We parked close to a Beijing Capital Airlines A330-300 that was preparing to depart for Qingdao (TAO).  I had no idea Beijing Capital Airlines operated long hauls much less a London route from Qingdao of all cities.


photo 20231222_214607

Compared to my previous LHR experiences, immigration was far faster and I was already at the taxi stand something like 15-20 minutes after deplaning.  Depending on the transit experience on my return flight, maybe I'll reconsider LHR as a connecting hub for Europe.

Display all

Product ratings

Airline

American Airlines 7.6

  • Cabin7.5 / 10
  • Cabin crew8.0 / 10
  • Entertainment/wifi9.0 / 10
  • Meal/catering6.0 / 10
Lounge

AA/BA Greenwich Lounge6.8

  • Comfort7.0 / 10
  • Meal/catering6.0 / 10
  • Entertainment/wifi6.0 / 10
  • Services8.0 / 10
Departure airport

New York - JFK8.4

  • Efficiency9.0 / 10
  • Access7.0 / 10
  • Services8.5 / 10
  • Cleanliness9.0 / 10
Arrival Airport

London - LHR8.6

  • Efficiency9.5 / 10
  • Access7.5 / 10
  • Services8.5 / 10
  • Cleanliness9.0 / 10

Conclusion

Lounge: The Greenwich Lounge was a bit lacking in terms of catering compared to the a la carte options available at one of its competitors. I'd describe this more akin to a very good Sky Club than a good international business lounge. That said, by US standards, the lounge was perfectly fine. I'm sure I would think it better if the coffee bar were already open.

Cabin & Seat: AA has the very competitive Super Diamond reverse herringbone seats on a majority of their 772s. It's a good seat, plenty of storage and space, albeit slightly lacking in the privacy department.

Service: Contrary to everything you hear about AA on FlyerTalk, I thought service was good and well-intentioned on this flight. Both FAs working the starboard aisle in back cabin were friendly and effective. Sandy especially was enthusiastic and always addressed me by name. Great job here and enough that I'd consider another long-haul flight on AA in the future if the schedule/price was right.

Meal & Catering: Catering was a bit lacking, but roughly on par with UA--perhaps with better slightly plating. Lacking a wine list when UA has reintroduced theirs seems like a competitive disadvantage though.

Bottom Line: This was a perfectly fine day flight to LHR from JFK. Given how short the flight was, these daytime flights from NYC are a revelation to me in terms jetlag. I was very fresh the next day. I'll note that I didn't expect much on a daytime flight, which might have affected my judgment of a lot of things--but overall this was a very convenient flight. I'm not sure whether AA is going to continue the 10am departure frequency--Googling doesn't show anything next week, but BA offers both a 6am and 8am out of JFK--a little too early to get to JFK for my taste, though not bad if you were already in Queens or at an airport hotel.

Did you enjoy reading this?

Let the author know by sharing a clap! It will be greatly appreciated!

7 Clap

YGeorgeW 's latest reviews

Comments (5)

  • Thanks for sharing! Definitely a toss up between UA and AA catering, but AA does have some pros. I think their lack of option for appetizer is excusable given that they at least make the effort to course the meal versus plopping everything down on a single tray. That beef looks sad just from the picture, and looks nothing like short rib.

    Pretty sloppy ground services to not put bedding on your seat, but overall AA looks a decent option though still a shade behind DL.

    JD actually has most of their long-haul fleet based out of TAO, also do MEL and SYD routes. The rest of them are in HGH, operating to LIS and MAD.

    • Thanks for reading NGO85!

      I have the lowest expectations for US carriers catering, so if it's palatable, it meets my expectations; certainly a ton of be improved. I would have prefered BA on this flight, but it was several hundred more expensive and just not worth it given that the Super Diamond seats are perfectly fine, especially on a daytime flight.

  • Oh hah we flew out of JFK just a few days appart around Christmas time. I was at the Soho lounge though.

    The “Greenwich” lounge is the old Flagship Lounge space but it seems the food offering has been downgraded slightly with the addition of the Chelsea and Soho Lounges. It’s nice to see they still have the champagne bar though.

    Nice that you got the Super Diamond seats and not the Concept D.

    The amenity is pretty basic, seen below. I grabbed what I needed and did not keep the kit.

    Haha so funny I did the same thing on my recent AA longhaul J flights. It’s weird how big the bag is being so empty.

    Overall the catering looks good by US carrier standards and at least AA make an effort to serve everything in courses unlike UA. I don’t might the lack of options for appetisers since it’s usually good and since there are multiple items on the appetiser tray you can take what you like and leave what you don’t. What I’m not happy about with AA J at the moment is the last of a printed wine list. Cabin crew have no idea what the wines are except whether it’s “Chardonnay” or “ A French blend” and even the champagne they only knew that it was French on my recent flights. Apparently they’re having supplier issues so they don’t have a set wine menu on any given flight or route like in the past .They just get whatever is available. As a Frenchman I might be making a bigger deal out of this …maybe most Americans don’t care…but when I pay for business out of pocket I want a decent wine list and I want to know what I’m drinking.

    Other than that everything looks good. Thanks for sharing!

    • Thanks for reading, Kevin!

      I was at the Soho lounge though.

      Well, some of us don't have OW status, haha

      Nice that you got the Super Diamond seats and not the Concept D.

      Looking at the flights, it seemed to be a bit inconsistent which they use on this route. I got lucky.

      As a Frenchman I might be making a bigger deal out of this …maybe most Americans don’t care

      Business wine lists tend to be meh outside Taiwanese carriers and Qatar. Even Air France when I last flew them had a rather disappointing wine selection in J for transatlantic. That said, I've really gotten into wine the last few years so perhaps my palate has just become too picky in this regard.

      • Business wine lists tend to be meh outside Taiwanese carriers and Qatar

        Oh for sure! I just wanna have a printed list to make sure I get the least crappy option ?

Login to post a comment.
Hi, it seems that you are using an ad blocker.

Flight-Report is a free website hosting more than 500 000 pictures and 17 000 reviews, without ads, this website can't exist.
We understand that ads can be annoying, this is why we only display a maximum of 2 non-invasive ads per page.
 
To continue using Flight-Report, we invite you to add Flight-Report to your blocker's "white list".
 

I have added Flight-Report on my white list

 
How to add Flight-Report to my white list?