Review of British Airways flight from London to New York in Business

BAW

BA - British Airways

Flight taken on 23 June 2024
BA115
15:09 08h 12m 18:21
Class Business
Seat 15A
YGeorgeW
1,830 · 89 · 2 · 38

First Trip to the Middle East


After spending a couple of days in London and catching up with an old friend, it was time to head home to the US.  This leg was a rescheduled part of an AA/BA ticket I bought in 2023–Etihad cancelling and delaying my flight from Bangkok at the beginning of 2024 meant I had to figure out what to do about this leg.  That's why I made this very roundabout trip back to the US from Cairo, stopping in each Dubai and London.


photo first-time-middle-east

British Airways First Wing


I took the Heathrow Express since it was quite convenient from where I was staying.  It was a smooth and efficient ride, albeit more expensive than other forms of public transportation.


photo 20240623_101816

It was a fairly normal day at Heathrow.  I had BA Gold status temporarily as a result of a status match–ended up not going for BA status in the end (and with the recent devaluation, I feel justified in my decision).  You have to head all the way to the end of the entrance to find the BA First Wing.


photo 20240623_104919-15585

After walking for a while, the First Wing (Gold/First Class check-in area) came into view.


photo 20240623_105139

There were plenty of passengers using the First Wing when I arrived, but also plenty of check-in counters so I only had a short wait.


photo 20240623_105210-27697

What took a lot longer was that there was a holdup at the document check because of some sort of computer system issue.


photo 20240623_105440-71280

The reason you go through the First Wing is because it has own security passage, which lets you out right into the BA Galleries First lounge.


photo 20240623_110524

British Airways Galleries First Lounge


Here is the back entrance to the lounge.  Interesting choice of decoration with the horse.


photo 20240623_110557

This lounge is massive, with tons of seating areas, but also packed given how many OneWorld Emerald passengers are going through Heathrow at any given time.  I'll let the pictures speak for themself as to what the seating situation is.





There is also a terrace of sorts that is more "out" in the terminal, it was also much quieter here than in the main part of the lounge.


photo 20240623_123245-93889

There were a variety beverage stations throughout the lounge: liquor, beer, coffee/tea, juice, and soft drinks are all readily available.





There were plenty of snack/food stations as well: including various baked goods, breakfast, fruit, and ice cream.





Hot breakfast and lunch were also available at the buffet, as well as cold food like sandwiches.





At the center of the lounge is a bar with a variety of wines, and a self-serve champagne bar.





I helped myself to some food from the buffet, which was decent.


photo 20240623_120732

Then I had a glass of Besserat de Bellefon Rose Champagne and some ice cream (the rose was fairly mediocre).


photo 20240623_112618

I realized at one of the tables that there is also a lounge web portal that allowed for orders (see below for the available wines in the lounge).  You can also directly reserve a shower from here.





While I didn't actually need a shower, one was available when I checked.


photo screenshot_20240623_120842_chrome

Walking around I noticed an old BEA livery A319:


photo 20240623_111830

Overall, because of how the lounge is set up, it's pretty hard to do any plane spotting from the lounge.


photo 20240623_123322

Individual gender-neutral bathrooms were available.  They were clean and plain, nothing much to report on.


photo 20240623_131602

BA provides Elemis amenities in the bathrooms.


photo 20240623_131604

After staying in the lounge for a couple of hours, I left through the front entrance to head to my gate.


photo 20240623_131725

BA115


Preboarding began at 1:36pm (4 minutes ahead of schedule), but in actuality it was just having people queue closer to the gate.  The FAs for the flight didn't show up until 1:46pm and boarding began in reality at 2:03pm.  It started first with a Group Zero (which I understood to be BA Gold Guest List, followed by BA Executive Gold).


photo 20240623_133104-31759

My flight back to the US would be on G-STBK, a 10-years-old Boeing 777-300ER.


photo 20240623_133002

BA's business class on the 77W is absolutely massive.   There is a mini cabin of 3 rows, then ~16 rows of 1-2-1 seats for a total of 76 business class seats.


photo 20240623_140557-71497

I was seated in 15A for this flight.  It's quite a striking seat.


photo 20240623_140718

At the end of the day, it's a reasonably modern Collins Super Diamond reverse herringbone seat.  The main difference is the addition of a door.





BA had its own branded headphones, which were decent.


photo 20240623_160526

A small White Company-branded amenity kit was waiting at my seat.  I was also shortly served with a glass of sparkling wine.


photo 20240623_141643

The contents of the kit are fairly standard and includes all of the usual amenities.


photo 20240623_141835

The retractable tray table slides out from right underneath the IFE.


photo 20240623_141724

BA has overhead compartments both on the side and in the center.  While travel bloggers love to talk about how open it makes the cabin feel without the central overhead storage, realistically it's much better to have it absent significant storage in the seats.


photo 20240623_142529

There was some sort of miscommunication with the ground crew regarding a pushback tug.  Apparently the ground crew was sure we had one, even though there clearly wasn't one.  This delay gave enough time for Julie, the IFM, to stop by and say hello.  I believe she was greeting all of the OW Emeralds and not everyone in J.  After a tug was found, there was yet another delay (unclear what the reason).

We pushed back at 3:09pm, but the captain immediately said that our takeoff time was actually a good bit later–we were just vacating the gate.  This gave the crew enough time to take everyone's orders before takeoff.  I asked for the chicken course.  At first the FA said they were out (does BA not guarantee OW Emerald or BA Gold their first choice of meals in business?).  Then after checking, turns out they had more available.


photo 20240623_141429

We finally took off at 3:53pm–roughly an hour late.  The captain promised to do their best make up time in the air.


photo 20240623_155421

Meal service started right after takeoff, so let's take a look at the menu.





10 minutes after takeoff, service began with a hot towel.


photo 20240623_160443

I asked for Digby Brut NV instead of the champagne.  I've had a good experience before with Rathfinny's sparkling wine and was curious to try Digby.  It wasn't as good, but maybe partially a result of being up in the air.  This took about 30 minutes to arrive after the hot towel.

In the meantime, the captain said that we would land around 5:45pm ET thanks to a faster flight plan.


photo 20240623_163355

It took another 43 minutes for the appetizer to arrive.  I know it's a large cabin, but this pace surprised me.  I had the roasted red pepper soup, which was pretty good.


photo 20240623_171656

The main came very quickly afterwards (which leads me to suspect the earlier delay was mostly a result of reheating most of the courses for the entire cabin).  I had the mushroom and kale stuffed British chicken.  It was a reasonably good dish (albeit rather dry as things tend to be in the air).


photo 20240623_174003

For dessert, I had the chocolate, walnut and orange cake, which was really sweet, but still quite good.


photo 20240623_180304

To polish it all off, I had some green tea before taking a nap.


photo 20240623_181225

After the meal service, I checked out the lavatory and changed into pajamas (from my previous Emirates flight).  As expected on a 777, it wasn't very big.


photo 20240623_181405

White Company, which also provides the amenity kit and pajamas (on long-haul flights).  


photo 20240623_181413

I returned to my seat and set up just the duvet so I could nap.  It was a reasonably short daytime flight after all.  I did not want to do much more than nap.


photo 20240623_184104

Here is what it looks like with the door closed.  The doors are locked on takeoff and landing, but has a tendency to get stuck (one of the FAs had to unstick the door several times so it could be opened/closed).


photo 20240623_183912

There is also a gap such that the door doesn't entirely closed.  Given that the height of the seat is rather low, the door doesn't add much privacy outside of when in lie-flat.  Otherwise it is rather easy to see over the door (unlike on QSuites).  Overall, it's better to have the door than not, but I wouldn't consider it such a vast improvement over an older Collins Super Diamond seat.

I woke up after taking a nap for about 2 hours and rang the call button to ask for a cup of green tea.  The tea never came.


photo 20240623_183916

Breakfast was served at roughly 70 minutes before landing.  I thought it was a nice touch to have an individual bread cup for the rolls.  Like lunch, it was also a reasonably tasty meal.


photo 20240623_181807

Soon we were flying over Long Island.


photo 20240623_191743

The Captain announced that we were expected to land at 5:55pm.


photo 20240623_192540

We touched down in reality at 6:07pm and arrived at our gate at 6:21pm.

Display all

Product ratings

Airline

British Airways 7.4

  • Cabin9.0 / 10
  • Cabin crew6.0 / 10
  • Entertainment/wifi7.0 / 10
  • Meal/catering7.5 / 10
Lounge

British Airways Galleries First 6.9

  • Comfort6.5 / 10
  • Meal/catering7.0 / 10
  • Entertainment/wifi7.0 / 10
  • Services7.0 / 10
Departure airport

London - LHR7.8

  • Efficiency6.0 / 10
  • Access8.0 / 10
  • Services8.0 / 10
  • Cleanliness9.0 / 10
Arrival Airport

New York - JFK6.8

  • Efficiency5.0 / 10
  • Access7.0 / 10
  • Services8.0 / 10
  • Cleanliness7.0 / 10

Conclusion

Lounge: The BA Galleries First Lounge is fine for a nice business class lounge, but a bit lacking for a true first class lounge. I understand that this is mainly OW elites, which I suppose is a function of its (perhaps) overly generous lounge access policy. It might be loud and packed most of the time, but it's still got plenty of seating and all the catering you'd expect in a good business class lounge.

Cabin & Seat: The Collins Super Diamond seat is already a good seat by itself and with a privacy door added, is even better. Compared to QSuites though, the door seems much more of a gimmick, as it feels flimsy and the seat's walls are not particularly high. This is not to take away from a great hard product, just noting that not all doors are created equal.

Service: Service was pleasant, but not particularly polished (for example, with the ordering confusion or the second green tea never being served). I didn't really ask for much throughout the flight and someone would respond fairly promptly if I pressed the call button (though follow through was apparently not as guaranteed).

Meal & Catering: I was reasonably pleased with the BA meal, though the service took a bit long to truly get started. Overall though, catering was fairly good for business class and even though I didn't sample much of the wine, it looked to be on par with competitors.

Bottom Line: BA offers a competitive product with lots of scheduled flight on a competitive route. I definitely prefer BA's product over AA's on this route, but haven't had a chance to compare with VS yet. When the price is right (and BA often has sales where it's reasonable), I wouldn't hesitate to fly them again. The Seat Selection fee for non-elites is a bit ridiculous though, but I understand this is where business class fares are heading.

Did you enjoy reading this?

Let the author know by sharing a clap! It will be greatly appreciated!

38 Clap

YGeorgeW 's latest reviews

Comments (2)

  • Hi George! Thanks for sharing this review on a very familiar product to me! Hah...I was through LHR and in the First lounge just the next day! It does get super crowded in there at peak times.

    I've had a good experience before with Rathfinny's sparkling wine and was curious to try Digby.

    I've been pleasantly surprised by British sparkling wines quite a few times on BA flights. Of course, the real champagnes are always better, but I'm always curious to try out the British Sparklings and they've been quite decent.

    does BA not guarantee OW Emerald or BA Gold their first choice of meals in business?

    Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahaha....nope. By virtue of liking to sit in the last row of J, I've not had my first choice on quite a few occasions as a OW Emerald or BA Gold. I've been either Emerald through AA or BA for the better part of the last decade, and it's definitely happened to me more often on BA than any other OW carrier.

    Overall, it's better to have the door than not, but I wouldn't consider it such a vast improvement over an older Collins Super Diamond seat.

    Exactly, I feel the same way. It's nice to have the door, but I like Super Diamond seat either way. They offer enough privacy already without a door and I often just leave the door open. But yeah, I do like it when sleeping.

    I definitely prefer BA's product over AA's on this route

    Or any TATL route for that matter...at least until AA finally introduce the new Flagship Suites...whenever that will be! Before the advent of the Club Suites, AA beat BA on hard product hands down. But BA always beat AA on soft product. Now BA have a better hard and soft product.

    Thanks for sharing! Always good to see others' opinions of BA through fresh eyes of those who don't fly them as regularly as I have. Lovely report as always!

    • Thanks for reading Kevin!

      I was through LHR and in the First lounge just the next day! It does get super crowded in there at peak times.

      Too bad we just missed each other! It would have been nice to meet in person.

      Of course, the real champagnes are always better, but I'm always curious to try out the British Sparklings and they've been quite decent.

      I would actually take Rathfinny over some real champagnes--there are plenty of bad champagnes out there that are popular in the US (like Veuve Cliquot's normal brut).

      Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahaha....nope.

      I guess that's one thing I'm thankful for as a 1K. As more airlines move to pre-ordering, this is becoming less of an issue though. Meanwhile, my father has reported multiple times of getting the business class meal in economy or premium economy on UA.

      But yeah, I do like it when sleeping.

      This is the main difference.

      Always good to see others' opinions of BA through fresh eyes of those who don't fly them as regularly as I have.

      I'm just waiting on a UA flight report from you.

Login to post a comment.
Flight-Report

Ad Blocker Detected

Flight-Report is a free website hosting more than 500 000 pictures and 17 000 reviews, without ads, this website can't exist.

If you enjoy our website, we would greatly appreciate it if you could disable your ad blocker to support us. Thank you for your help and understanding!

How to Allow Flight-Report.com?