Review of Citilink Indonesia flight Surabaya Semarang-Java Island in Economy

Airline Citilink Indonesia
Flight QG800
Class Economy
Seat 15D
Aircraft Airbus A320
Flight time 00:55
Take-off 07 Jun 18, 09:30
Arrival at 07 Jun 18, 10:25
QG 13 reviews
Eric V P
By SILVER 251
Published on 6th July 2018
Report #36: QG800 - A taste of the new terminal

This will be my report on flying on Citilink economy class from Surabaya SUB to Semarang SRG, a short-haul intercity flight within Java island, on board their Airbus A320-200. This review will be also the first review of the new SRG terminal here, opened just the day before, so read on!

A fair warning: this report will be shorter than usual, especially on the on board part (or call this as more of an airport review?), as I took some rest while on board and the seating prevented me from taking many pictures of the outside. Rest assured, however, that most other reports in the series will feature the usual level of detail expected.

Here are the 12 parts of the trip:
KUL - CGK on KLM 777-200ER business class: Read here
CGK - SUB on Garuda Indonesia 737 MAX 8 economy class: Read here
SUB - SRG on Citilink A320-200 economy class: You are here
SRG - SUB on Garuda Indonesia CRJ-1000ER economy class: Read here
SUB - KJT on Citilink A320-200 economy class: Read here (first commercial flight to KJT)
KJT - SUB on Citilink A320-200 economy class: Read here (first commercial flight from KJT)
SUB - DPS on Garuda Indonesia 737-800 economy class: Publishing soon
DPS - SIN on KLM 777-300ER economy class: Publishing soon
SIN - DPS on Jetstar Airways A320 economy class: Publishing soon
DPS - CGK on Lion Air 747-400 economy/business class: Read here
SUB - CGK on Garuda Indonesia 737 MAX 8 business class: Publishing soon
CGK - SIN on Lion Air 737-900ER economy class: Publishing soon

Background


As much as I like spending time in SUB, the main goal for this trip was to sample as many different offerings as possible within the Garuda Indonesia group (note that QG is GA's low-cost arm). Therefore, I decided to fill the afternoon with a roundtrip to sample GA's regional product at least once.

It was a very close contest between flying on GA's AT7 to Banyuwangi BWX and back on the exact same plane and QG's 320 to SRG and back to SUB by GA's CRK, I opted for the latter mainly out of the dangerously close connecting time in BWX, but also flying to SRG would also allow me to revisit the town after a while (note that I had barely any idea of the new terminal, so that was out of the equation).

The prorated fare after OTA discount came at Rp294.000 (US$21), which was cheap as the direction goes toward Jakarta (on the Mudik period before Ied generally flights going away from Jakarta are the expensive ones while those going towards Jakarta are rock-bottom cheap).
photo qg800 ga367 07062018 receipt

Trip to SUB and check-in


If you had read my previous CGK-SUB review you would notice that I made an interterminal connection by bus. However, for the sake of thoroughness I would copy it to the one below:

I made my way to the kerbside where the interterminal shuttle bus was waiting.
photo 20180607_090250

The bus was decorated with a view of the Bromo mountain nearby as well as the tourism ambassadors for the province.
photo 20180607_090313

The seat was tight, but for a 10 minutes ride I wouldn't expect much.
photo 20180607_090324

After 10 minutes of waiting we left the terminal 2 to the terminal 1.
photo 20180607_091628

We went through the dedicated road, which allowed for a bit of spotting.
photo 20180607_092234photo 20180607_092458

I soon reached the terminal and proceeded to the terminal 1A, used by ID, QG, and FS as well as Umrah flights.
photo 20180607_093352photo 20180607_093359

The public area is located at the kerbside, featuring mostly eateries and a handful of convenience stores.
photo 20180607_093441photo 20180607_093445

Departure FIDS of the morning.
photo 20180607_093455

After passing through the preliminary ticket and security check I went to the check-in counters. Check-in was fast, however with QG being QG any seat change would incur a fee, including requesting for any window seat, so I opted for the earlier seat assignment on web check-in.
photo 20180607_093855

My boarding pass of the day.
photo 20180607_095900

As SUB terminal 1 now moved away from doing proper security screening at the gate, the second staircase was disabled to make way for wrapping services.
photo 20180607_094417

It was a short escalator ride to the departure floor.
photo 20180607_094453

First it was the ticket check.
photo 20180607_094516

Security was acceptable and I went through in a couple of minutes.
photo 20180607_094551photo 20180607_094836

SUB transit area and departure


The transit area consisted of a long corridor with some eateries and lounges. Now that the terminal has been used mostly for domestic flights, the entire area apart from the Umrah gate at the very end was opened.
photo 20180607_094842photo 20180607_094846

A placard showing the rights for delayed flights in Indonesia.
photo 20180607_095133

In Indonesia we didn't impose the LAG restriction for domestic flights so machines for LAG screening as well as immigration counters were prepared for Umrah flights.
photo 20180607_095320

A view of the gate. Also note the Surya newspapers provided.
photo 20180607_095434

The plane of the late morning was PK-GQL, a 2 3/4 years old 320, which had just arrived from BDJ.
photo 20180607_095912photo 20180607_095916

Boarding commenced later on, with priority enforced.
photo 20180607_101724

I proceeded through the corridor.
photo 20180607_101827

After that it was a short walk down the aerobridge,
photo 20180607_101851

The queue was minor and I soon made my way on board.
photo 20180607_101921

The ownership plate of the plane.
photo 20180607_101947

On board


Flight: QG800
Plane: PK-GQL
STD/ATD: 09.30/09.44
STA/ATA: 10.25/10.29
Load factor: 73% Y (131/180)
Seat type: Standard economy class (aisle seat)
Details: https://flightaware.com/live/flight/PKGQL/history/20180607/0244Z/WARR/WAHS

After I was welcomed by Ms. Rani (the purser on the SUB-KJT and KJT-SUB flights) I made .my way back to the cabin.
photo 20180607_102017

Seat tour: as an otherwise normal 320 the seatbelt also used the normal design.
photo 20180607_102228

Typical on a QG flight, the inflight menu was there.
photo 20180607_102357

A safety card was also present.
photo 20180607_102404

The magazines were there as well.
photo 20180607_102429photo 20180607_102435

Last but not least, the plastic airsickness bag.
photo 20180607_102451

Typical on a 180 seat 320, the legroom was tight.
photo 20180607_102545

A standard recline button also existed.
photo 20180607_104900

Me on the seat.
photo 20180607_110702

The flight attendants soon prepared for the safety demonstration.
photo 20180607_102613

After takeoff I went to check the lavatory, which was clean.
photo 20180607_105140

Some of the signages were also translated into Chinese.
photo 20180607_105145

Is it a QG thing not to have the sink stopper?
photo 20180607_105152

The 320 galley.
photo 20180607_105422

A view of the cabin from behind. Also note the flight attendants doing drink service for those paying for the seats as well as the sales round.
photo 20180607_105437

Some views during the cruise.
photo 20180607_105643photo 20180607_105648

The flight passed by the Java island's northern coast.
photo 20180607_110039

The entire flight happened to be uneventful apart from the ending word from the pilot, "Welcome to (sic) new terminal, Achmad Yani International Airport". I had planned on trying the old terminal, but that needed to be shelved indefinitely and I went through the aerobridge.
photo 20180607_113358

There were no other plane beside us.
photo 20180607_113412

A helicopter was strangely found, so
photo 20180607_113419photo 20180607_113429

Arrival at SRG and post-arrival trip

The signage leading to the arrival area.
photo 20180607_113439

A view of the gate, where I would be at a few hours later.
photo 20180607_113443

It was a short escalator ride to the domestic arrival area.
photo 20180607_113451

At first it was a short walk passing by the glass door.
photo 20180607_113508

A short walk down the arrival corridor followed.
photo 20180607_113523photo 20180607_113527

The walk brought me to the luggage claim area.
photo 20180607_113640

The arrival building, like those in many newer Indonesian airports, feature high ceiling and modern design instead of focusing on feeling more local.
photo 20180607_113655

The luggage claim area.
photo 20180607_113712

A handful of kiosks right before exiting the arrival building.
photo 20180607_113741

The walk to the public area involved a short walk down the sheltered, but otherwise open walkway.
photo 20180607_113743

From the public area I made my way out to the kerbside.
photo 20180607_113908

Seats had been prepared for the opening ceremony by Indonesia's president.
photo 20180607_114030photo 20180607_114055

A view of the arrival building from the outside.
photo 20180607_114202

The ceremony would be held on the first kerbside, so only the second one was activated for traffic. From the second kerbside at the left end you could take BRT services downtown, which was reasonably priced.
photo 20180607_114207
See more

Verdict

Citilink Indonesia

4.3/10
Cabin5.0
Cabin crew6.5
Entertainment2.5
Buy on board3.0

Surabaya - SUB

6.4/10
Efficiency7.0
Access5.0
Services7.0
Cleanliness6.5

Semarang-Java Island - SRG

7.1/10
Efficiency8.0
Access6.0
Services7.0
Cleanliness7.5

Conclusion

Apart from the inability to change between normal seats for free, QG offered a bearable way to travel low-cost on the route, which didn't say much due to the short distance and therefore less need for service. In terms of the airport, SUB terminal 1, while dated, was still quite efficient and provided adequate services. The new SRG terminal left a positive impression with its modern design and especially the additional amenities compared with the old terminal such as aerobridge availability.

On overall, QG offered a decently priced alternative to intercity trains to get to Semarang from Surabaya.

Some thing done well for the trip (airports):
+ Fast check-in at SUB
+ Acceptable security at SUB
+ Modern terminal at SRG
+ Reasonably priced transport option at SRG

Some thing done well for the trip (on board):
+ Reasonable price (Rp294.000 (US$21))
+ Free newspaper provision
+ Reasonably new plane
+ Clean lavatory

Things that can be improved (airports):
- Interterminal bus frequency at SUB
- Dated terminal at SUB
- Crowd at SRG (or was it because of people traveling to the airport itself?)

Things that can be improved (on board):
- Inability to change seats free of charge
- Tight legroom

Related

4 Comments

  • Comment 453369 by
    Davidbom 4 Comments

    The new terminal at semarang seems quite nice, and yes i agree that sub terminal 1 is very dated but still very comfortable if its not crowded.... Nice report btw!

    • Comment 453451 by
      Eric V P SILVER AUTHOR 88 Comments

      Hi!

      The new terminal at semarang seems quite nice
      - I wouldn't say of it as bad, but it still felt a bit crowded to my liking and there weren't much retail options inside (more of it on my next installment departing from SRG).

      Hope you enjoyed the review - stay tuned for the rest of the series!

  • Comment 453429 by
    marathon GOLD 8522 Comments

    How much was the fee for a window seat ?
    Moving the security check away from the gate is a good thing, IMO.
    Quite self-explanatory "passenger rights" sign - I had a doubt for case #6 and Google Translate helped me.
    Interesting additional security check for international flights - I did not know LAG restrictions do not apply to domestic flights in Indonesia.
    I did not realize that this report was that much shorter than usual, overall ;)
    Thanks for sharing !

    • Comment 453450 by
      Eric V P SILVER AUTHOR 88 Comments

      Hi!

      How much was the fee for a window seat ?
      - It was starting from Rp30.000 (US$2.1/€1.9), but that's not the point - 3K/JQ would be more than happy to change your seat assignment for free upon asking at their counter during check-in (as long as you don't ask for anything specific) and JT/IW won't charge a dime for any seat including in exit rows so that didn't look particularly good for QG.

      Moving the security check away from the gate is a good thing, IMO.
      - Agreed on that as well.

      Interesting additional security check for international flights - I did not know LAG restrictions do not apply to domestic flights in Indonesia.
      - I wouldn't say of it as additional as in most cases those departing on international flights get their own security + LAG check (e.g. from SUB terminal 2, CGK, DPS) but on those with less international flights such as JOG that may also happen.

      I did not realize that this report was that much shorter than usual, overall ;)
      - Then wait for my other reports in the series - there are still 6 of them :p

      Thank you for reading!

Login to post a comment.