Review of United flight from San Francisco to Honolulu in Economy

UAL

UA - United

Flight taken on 24 November 2024
UA300
13:40 05h 35m 17:15
Class Economy
Seat -
NGO85
595 · 78 · 2 · 15

Background


This series covers a recent trip down to Oahu. The outbound flight was booked on UA from SFO to HNL, there are a hodgepodge of planes used on this route (B737, B757, B777). We picked the 13:40 departure to get into HNL in time for dinner (or so we thought). This choice left us with a B772 in the retro-UA cabins (B77G configuration), which are probably about as bad as it gets in all cabins (J is 2-4-2 and Y is 3-4-3).


Routing


Flight routing


Check-in/Security


We arrived at SFO T2 about 2 hours before departure. After doing the bag drop at the PremierAccess area, we head off towards security.


photo 4

As has been a common occurrence recently, the TSA PreCheck line is longer than regular security. We are airside in less than 5 minutes so no major complaints.


photo 5-60955

Our plane is leaving from Concourse F, but we head straight past the United Club at Concourse E and walk over to Concourse D.


photo 6

No surprises at who runs the show here at T2.


photo 7

Air Canada Maple Leaf Lounge


At Concourse D, we head upstairs to head into the Maple Leaf Lounge.


photo 8

A quick stroll through the seating areas near the entrance, which are bathed by natural light and have good tarmac views.


photo 9-86884

Straight back to the dining room area in the back.


photo 10

The hot buffet items along with 2 soups (to the right). The empty items were replaced after the photo.


photo 11

The lunch offering.


photo 12

The mural of San Francisco in the lounge.


photo 15

The lounge also has its own outdoor terrace, which is always a nice space to get some fresh air and sunshine while watching the movements below.


photo 16

The arrival of the KL B78X is always a highlight for my son.


photo 13photo 14

With the arrival of our plane from IAH, we get up and leave the lounge to head back to Concourse F.


photo 17

Pre-flight


The UA overflow into Concourse D.


photo 18

The walk back through Concourse E.


photo 19

The new temporary connector to Concourses F/G now that renovations are finally underway.


photo 20-85166

Our plane was due to leave from F22, so we have the long walk all the way to the far reaches of the fork.


photo 21

A UA B789 prepping for a rotation to ORD.


photo 22

Our plane today will be N212UA, a 2000-built B772 that has been with United its entire 24-year history. Given its age, it is no surprise that it will have the retro-UA cabins with a 77G configuration featuring 28 business seats in a 2-4-2 configuration and 336 Y economy seats in a 3-4-3 configuration to operate high-density domestic hub rotations.


photo 23

Boarding


After pre-boarding which contained ~50-75 people, we boarded with Group 1 in the ~100 people queue.


photo 24

We were greeted with our DIY cabin cleaning equipment and coldly asked if we knew which aisle to use. What surprised me is that there were no kids packs on this leisure route, we got them on almost every other domestic route this year.


Making our way to our seats in the rear of the first economy cabin. The plane has not aged well and is as dark, drab, and yellow as the photo suggests.


photo 25-90117

A strafing shot of an Economy Plus row enroute.


photo 26

Blankets were pre-placed on the seats, but no pillows.


photo 27

Seat pitch is only 31", but thanks to the removal of in-flight magazines feels better. However, at 17" width feels very narrow and tight.


photo 60

Our DIY cleaning kit handed out at boarding to clean the dirty tray tables.


photo 28

Poorly placed controls in the top of the armrest that are easy to bump with your elbow, which is maybe why the crew ignore the call buttons?


photo 29

The view from our seat will be of the large shiny wing.


photo 30

The seat back contents are a crumpled up safety card that had pages stuck together with something sticky, service menu, and some trash.


photo 31

No in-seat IFE, it will be the standard streaming services. The seat does contain a device holder.


photo 34photo 32

The advertised in-seat power will remain red (inactive) throughout the flight, the row ahead of us was green and across the aisle was green. There are no USB ports in these seats.


photo 33

The BOB menu, UA has only returned complimentary meals on longer flights to Hawaii.


photo 35photo 36

UA didn't skimp in installing overhead air vents, but everything was misaligned with the re-configuration (densification) of the plane so the overhead lights were useless since they were pointed behind our heads.


photo 37

Flight


We completed boarding, but the front door didn't close. At 13:20, the pilot made an announcement were waiting for crew, which in my mind meant for our flight. After another 20 minutes, he came back on and announced we were still waiting for crew to board since we would need to shuttle a couple of B787 crew to HNL to recover a plane that had problems in-flight and had to divert to HNL from SIN. No idea why they needed to delay our flight an hour versus just putting them on the flight that was due to leave ~90 minutes after us, but that's UA.


We finally push back at 14:20 and the safety demonstration is done manually since there are no screens on the plane.


photo 39

Luckily from Concourse F, it is a short taxi to the runways. Crossing a UA B737.


photo 40

Speaking of incapacitated planes, F-GZNC was stuck at SFO after the cancellation of AF83 the day before.


photo 38

We quickly reach the end of the airport and swing around to align on runway 28L.


photo 41photo 42

We had a rolling take off at 14:33 almost an hour late, but get some good glimpses of SFO as we start our trek to the coast.


photo 44photo 45photo 46

Crossing the 101.


photo 47

Last views of the mainland as we turn to start our trek across the Pacific to the southwest.


photo 48photo 49photo 50

Our route out of SFO.


photo 2

As soon as we leveled off, the agriculture declarations were handed out.


photo 51

Service soon followed with the distribution of snacks.


photo 52

Knowing we wouldn't have the chance to eat again for >5 hours, we went ahead and partook in the limited BOB offerings. The cheese and fruit tray:


photo 53

The Pretzel Beer Cheeseburger:


photo 54photo 55

Drinks were then offered and full cans were provided.


photo 57

There is no in-seat IFE, it can all be accessed through the Wi-Fi streaming services. Wi-Fi itself is available for $10 ($8 for UA MileagePlus members), which is decent value given the flight length.


photo 82

About halfway through the flight, we saw a flight attendant passing out waters. He gave me the last cup and said he would come grab a new bottle to give one to my wife. He returned 5 minutes later and apologized saying he was told not to distribute water.


photo 59photo 58

Nothing to see the whole flight, but clouds over the Pacific. About 90-minutes before arrival, the crew came on and announced that since there might be turbulence approaching Hawaii, they would cancel the second service.


photo 62

As the plane started its descent, glasses of water were handed out. The promised turbulence never happened and the seat belt sign never turned on, so assume the cancellation of the second service was down to pure laziness of the hidden crew. Our son was hungry, so he asked if they had any pretzels left over, the FA handing out water just dismissively said no.


photo 61photo 63

First sight of land as we pass north of Molokai.


photo 64

The approach into HNL.


photo 3

First sight of Oahu.


photo 65

Crossing over Waikiki.


photo 67

Golden hour is in full effect as we align for arrival into HNL.


photo 68photo 69photo 70

We touch down on runway 8L at 17:48, over 30 minutes late.


photo 71

Spoilers deployed as we exit the runway to get a glimpse of the sunset.


photo 72photo 73

We pull into our gate at HNL T2 at 17:53.


photo 74

Strafing shot of the center sections as we deplane through L2.


photo 75-53835

Since we arrived in G, we have a long walk back to the main terminal.


photo 76

The highlight of HNL T2 is the outdoor walkways between concourses allowing for some nice smells of jet fuel and plane spotting.


photo 79photo 78

Back inside, we will head down to the baggage claim. Priority bags will of course not be respected by UA so ours will be one of the last to circulate and we will finally leave the airport around 18:30.


photo 80photo 81

I'll leave off this series here as we start our stay in Oahu, thanks for stopping by!


Flight Information


United Airlines, UA300
Equipment: Boeing B777-200 [N212UA, delivered July 2020]
Departure: 13:40 (ATD: 14:33)
Arrival: 17:15 (ATA: 17:48)
Flight time: 5:15


photo 1
Display all

Product ratings

Airline

United 5.8

  • Cabin6.0 / 10
  • Cabin crew5.0 / 10
  • Entertainment/wifi7.0 / 10
  • Meal/catering5.0 / 10
Departure airport

San Francisco - SFO8.0

  • Efficiency8.0 / 10
  • Access7.0 / 10
  • Services8.0 / 10
  • Cleanliness9.0 / 10
Arrival Airport

Honolulu - HNL6.5

  • Efficiency6.0 / 10
  • Access6.0 / 10
  • Services6.0 / 10
  • Cleanliness8.0 / 10

Conclusion

A standard near-LCC domestic experience on UA with old planes, grumpy crews, and an overall underwhelming service. The domestic B772s are about as bad as they get with cramped cabins (though the seat itself was fairly comfortably padded for a >5h flight), dirty seats and tray tables, and very poor air quality on the ~25 year old frame. Grumpy cabin crews who were hiding in the galleys throughout the flight and I feel it is pretty bad when an FA who was trying to hand out water has to apologize to us after getting reprimanded for doing so. UA's IFE is their one strength, but broken power ports penalize the score. A single drink service on a >5h flight (plus an additional 1h delay sitting in the plane waiting for UA crew to board) and the BOB is pretty poor to average in terms of quality/value so you are probably best bringing your own food on board.

Did you enjoy reading this?

Let the author know by sharing a clap! It will be greatly appreciated!

15 Clap

NGO85 's latest reviews

Comments (2)

  • It's sad that the big US carriers tend to put their worst cabin products on Hawaii. I never understood why since fares to Hawaii are always seem to be high compared to similar duration transcon flights. I guess it's cool to get a widebody, but these domestic 777s are about as basic as you can get. Thank goodness there's at least streaming IFE.

    Thanks for sharing!

    • Hi Kevin, thanks for stopping by. The Hawaii routes are cash cows, they definitely target maximizing profit margins using the highest density planes (Y336 in the 77G/77M). If I remember correctly, UA wanted $1300-1500 more for domestic F on this flight booking >9 months out, and people clearly pay it with the cabin 100% full and no upgrades.

Login to post a comment.
Flight-Report

Ad Blocker Detected

Flight-Report is a free website hosting more than 500 000 pictures and 17 000 reviews, without ads, this website can't exist.

If you enjoy our website, we would greatly appreciate it if you could disable your ad blocker to support us. Thank you for your help and understanding!

How to Allow Flight-Report.com?