Review of American Airlines flight Boston Dallas-Fort Worth in First

Airline American Airlines
Flight AA1211
Class First
Seat 4A
Aircraft Airbus A321
Flight time 04:35
Take-off 09 Dec 17, 13:50
Arrival at 09 Dec 17, 17:25
AA   #65 out of 122 Airlines A minimum of 20 Flight-Reports is required in order to appear in the rankings. 341 reviews
KévinDC
By SILVER 1515
Published on 8th April 2018
Hello and welcome to the second report in this series of flights!

For many of us on the Frequent Flyer status hamster wheel, December can be mileage run season if you need just that little bit more to maintain status or make it to that next level for the year. However, since the introduction of spend requirements by U.S. carriers several years ago, mileage runs have generally become less useful in the pursuit of status. In fact, I hadn't done a true mileage run in years.

I wasn't originally planning on doing a mileage run but, being just under 10K EQMs (AA Elite Qualifying Miles) away from the next status level by the end of November and no December AA flying planned, I decided to go for it.

Planning



With the Holidays around the corner, I didn't have much time to spare so I booked a reasonably-priced multi-segment trip to the West Coast in First/Business returning the same day. I specifically booked the Premium cabins because discounted First/Business fares earn double EQMs (full-fare F/J earn 3X EQMs), allowing me to cut the distance needed to earn 10K EQMs in half and doing it in a reasonably comfortable way. In the end, I earned 11,392 EQMs for the trip, which worked out to 7.03 CPM (Cents Per Mile)–a decent rate for premium cabin travel.

While true low-CPM mileage runs in Economy have mostly become a thing of the past for U.S.-based frequent flyers, Premium cabin EQM/EQD runs can still be worth it when decent fares are found, especially if you're an #AvGeek and don't mind flying just for the sake of flying.

As I mentioned earlier, this trip was booked using the multi-city function on AA.com. There are nonstop AA flights from DC to the West Coast; however, direct flights would only yield about 9000 EQMs (4,500 actual flown miles). The goal being to fly over 5000 miles to comfortably earn over 10K EQMs, I needed to fly to a city to the east of DC and backtrack to the West Coast, so I decided on Boston. The itinerary was originally booked as: DCA ✈ BOS ✈ DFW ✈ LAX ✈ PHX ✈ DCA

I could have done BOS-LAX nonstop; however, I routed myself through DFW intentionally to try the B789, which I will cover in the 3rd report in this series. I would have also preferred a nonstop LAX-DCA for the return, unfortunately there was no red-eye to DC that evening so flying home via PHX was the faster option….at least that was the plan.

This is how this trip was supposed to go:

photo 1 original mileage run map

Due to a delay down the line, this is how it ended up:

photo 2 final mileage run map

When piecing together these types of quick trips with so many segments there is always a good chance that something will go wrong. If something were to go wrong, I expected that it would be in the first few segments as a snowstorm was bearing down on the northeast U.S. that day. Ironically, despite the snow, the first three flights were generally on-time–the problems arose in LAX.

Reports in this series:

Washington Reagan DCA ✈ Boston Logan BOS | American Airlines, E190, Domestic First Class
Boston Logan Intl BOS ✈ Dallas Fort Worth DFW | American Airlines, A321-200, Domestic First Class
Dallas Fort Worth DFW ✈ Los Angeles Intl LAX | American Airlines, B787-9, Business Class

Pre-Flight & Boarding



Having arrived a little over 30 minutes late due to a de-icing delay on departure from DC, I had less time to make it to my next flight, but still had a comfortable cushion.

Despite the snow most flights out of Boston were showing on time, including mine.

photo img_9348

I would have liked to have time to visit one of the Priority Pass lounges, but only had about 10 minutes before boarding so I just headed straight to the gate.

photo img_9344

A view of the iconic BOS control tower on the way to the gate.

photo img_9347

Here is our ride to Dallas–a new-ish A321 with sharklets.

photo img_9345

We'll definitely be needing de-icing

photo img_9346

Boarding began right on time with Concierge Key, then the premium cabin.

Pre-merger AA A321s have the same seats in domestic First as the 737s with Boeing Sky Interior and IFE.

photo img_9350

When booking on AA.com, you can distinguish between PMAA and PMUS A321s by the description of the Aircraft. PMAA A321s are labeled "32B-Airbus A321 (Sharklets)"–not to be confused with 32T, the Transcon A321s with First Class and lie-flat Business class. PMUS A321s are simply labeled 321; I usually avoid these on longer flights as they have no IFE or in-seat power.

Good legroom at the standard PMAA 40" pitch in Domestic First.

photo img_9351

Not much of a view for the moment

photo img_9354

Though the IFE is touchscreen, there are also remote controls in the armrests.

photo img_9353

When the snowed slipped off the window, I could see the storm was still raging.

photo img_9355

Shortly after getting settled in, I was surprised when a flight attendant came by to take orders for pre-departure drinks. Not only are pre-departure drinks rarely done by PMAA crews on domestic flights, but when they are, in my experience, it's usually just a choice of water and orange juice. To be fair, PDB service is more common on longer domestic flights, but it really is hit or miss on PMAA metal. For this flight we had a choice of anything from the bar so I had a coffee and Baileys.

photo img_9357

During boarding I could see several planes pushing back and being de-iced. Unlike DCA where aircraft line up for de-icing on a remote stand, for which we waited an hour on my DCA-BOS flight, AA de-ices aircraft at the gates in Boston, which is much more efficient.

photo img_9360

The Flight



We pushed back several minutes early and de-icing began immediately as a truck was on standby. As I was saying, they're much more efficient at handling snow in BOS than DCA–but then again, New Englanders deal with snow more often than Washingtonians.

photo img_9359

The de-icing only took a few minutes and we were off.

We taxied past Cape Air parking stand. It looks like a baby airplane nursery :-P

photo img_9361

Lining up on the runway and takeoff




Snowy Boston on takeoff.

photo img_9365photo img_9366

Once we got above the snowstorm we found blue skies again.

photo img_9368

Unfortunately, my IFE, along with several others', wasn't working and despite multiple attempts by the cabin crew to re-start the system, mine never came up. It's a shame to have an aircraft with IFE and not be able to take advantage of it. Luckily, I had my tablet to have some entertainment on this 4 hour flight.

photo img_9367

About a half hour into the flight, the lunch service began. It started out with warm nuts and a pre-meal drink. As it was a Saturday around brunch time, I had a mimosa (sparkling wine and orange juice).

photo img_9369

When your IFE screen isn't working there's always the view outside the window, at least once the clouds started to break up as we flew away from the snowstorm.

photo img_9372

There were three options for lunch, including one vegetarian option as usual. Though AA domestic First catering can be hit or miss, I've been seeing some creative options lately and on this flight I was pleasantly surprised to see a Vietnamese Rice Noodle salad with chicken as an option. Aside from being an "exotic" dish for a domestic flight, it was quite tasty.

photo img_9370

Looking out the window, I was surprised to see we were flying on the Canadian side of the Great Lakes. It look like we took a long route to get around the snowstorm.

photo img_9373

For dessert, a simple cheesecake.

photo img_9374

The F cabin in the dark after the meal service.

photo img_4518

After lunch, I read for a bit and took a nap. This particular model of seats found on newer A321s and 737s with IFE are quite comfortable with soft adjustable headrests, good cushioning and decent recline. In my opinion, these rather rare seats in the AA domestic fleet are better than the even-newer-model seats that are being installed on some refitted PMUS aircraft and older AA 737s–the newer Domestic First seats are the same seats being installed in Premium Economy on the long-haul fleet.

I woke up as we were making our descent into DFW.

photo img_9375

Flying over DAL - Dallas Love Field, a major Southwest Airlines operation and site of the airline's headquarters.

photo img_9377photo img_9378

Downtown Dallas and the Trinity River

photo img_9379photo img_9380

Nice sunset colors as we land.

photo img_9381

AT&T Stadium (Cowboys Stadium)

photo img_9383photo img_9384

Despite the odd northerly route, we landed on-time.

photo img_9385photo img_9386

Last rays of sunlight as we taxi to our gate.

photo img_9388

We parked at Terminal C, where we arrived at the gate right on time, so I had plenty of time to get to Terminal D and my 787-9 flight to LAX.

photo img_9389

Our northerly route and the impressive snowstorm bearing down on the East coast.

photo aa1211 bos-dfw route

Thanks for reading!
See more

Verdict

American Airlines

7.0/10
Cabin8.5
Cabin crew8.0
Entertainment3.5
Meal/catering8.0

Boston - BOS

8.1/10
Efficiency8.5
Access8.0
Services8.0
Cleanliness8.0

Dallas-Fort Worth - DFW

8.3/10
Efficiency7.5
Access8.0
Services9.0
Cleanliness8.5

Conclusion

A good flight in a comfortable cabin with a pleasant and attentive cabin crew. It would have been an even better flight had the IFE worked. The catering was good and refreshingly different.

Related

6 Comments

  • Comment 440135 by
    Rl 777 812 Comments

    Thank you for sharing this FR with us!

    “Here is our ride to Dallas–a new-ish A321 with sharklets.”
    - Wonderful shot, especially with the presence of snow on the fuselage.

    “ Not much of a view for the moment”
    - Still a cool shot IMO.

    Your aerial photography game is always on top. Great pictures!

    Wow, what a sunset!!!

    Have a good one, see you later.

    • Comment 440558 by
      KévinDC TEAM SILVER AUTHOR 4313 Comments

      Hi Rl777, thanks for your comments!

      "especially with the presence of snow on the fuselage"
      - The aircraft had overnighted in BOS so the heavy wet snow had time to accumulate.

      Thanks for the kind words!

  • Comment 440215 by
    KL651 TEAM 3999 Comments

    Thanks for this FR gurrl
    Wow so much snow in Boston and yet no delays, they sure are used to it.
    The same thing in NYC would mean a shutdown of ops!
    Decent service and indeed not the usual "chicken or pasta", was there any additional service before landing on this longish domestic flight?

    • Comment 440560 by
      KévinDC TEAM SILVER AUTHOR 4313 Comments

      "Wow so much snow in Boston and yet no delays, they sure are used to it."
      - Mmmm Hmmm that's for sure. In DC we barely had any snow and it took an hour for deicing.

      "The same thing in NYC would mean a shutdown of ops!"
      - Pretty much, but then again NYC airports are so congested that anytime it rains everything gets backed up.

      "was there any additional service before landing on this longish domestic flight?"
      - I'm sure they passed around the snack basket later on in the flight but I was getting my beauty sleep ^^

  • Comment 440370 by
    jetsetpanda SILVER 2243 Comments

    Hi Kevin and thank you for sharing another awesome FR.

    "For many of us on the Frequent Flyer status hamster wheel..."
    - It's been more than a year since I've flown AA. I'm free!! :P

    "Luckily, I had my tablet to have some entertainment on this 4 hour flight."
    - The sign of a seasoned traveler.

    "There were three options for lunch, including one vegetarian option as usual."
    - Looks like AA catering has improved.

    Lovely pics as usual. Nice landing into DFW.

    • Comment 440561 by
      KévinDC TEAM SILVER AUTHOR 4313 Comments

      Hey Adan, thanks for your kind words!

      "It's been more than a year since I've flown AA. I'm free!! :P"
      - Free at last, free at last! Good for you...I'm too afraid to jump off the hamster wheel

      "Looks like AA catering has improved."
      - It's still hit or miss. Sometimes you get pleasant surprises like this flight, but it's often still kinda meh. Definitely not back to PMAA levels.

      Thanks!

Login to post a comment.